How this guide is made
Who is responsible for the Supplements A–Z guide, the botanical finder and the encyclopedia, which sources they accept, how evidence is graded, how each statement is checked, and how to tell us about a mistake.
Who is responsible
The guide is published by EUTECNIQ Sciences, a company in formation, which sets the standards on this page and is accountable for what is published. EUTECNIQ sells no supplements today, carries no advertising and has no affiliate links: no page in the guide earns money from what it says about an ingredient.
Which sources count
- Government and regulatory sources: NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, NCCIH, NIH LiverTox, FDA, eCFR, the European Medicines Agency (HMPC monographs), EFSA, Health Canada, Australia's TGA, WHO, IARC and the US National Toxicology Program.
- Peer-reviewed literature: systematic reviews and meta-analyses first, then randomized trials, then other human studies, read in the journal or through PubMed.
- Reference databases: Kew's Plants of the World Online and World Checklist for names and native ranges, the IUCN Red List category as served by GBIF for conservation status, CITES Species+ for trade listings, PubChem for chemical properties, and the ABC-AHP-NCNPR Botanical Adulterants Prevention Program for adulteration.
Vendor pages, brand sites, blogs and Wikipedia are not used as sources. Numbers are given as the source states them, with its units, population and duration. A question no opened source answers is marked “No published information found in the sources checked”, never filled in.
How evidence is graded
Each topic studied for an ingredient gets one grade, describing the human evidence in the cited source, not a recommendation:
- A
- Consistent results from several randomized trials or a systematic review of them
- B
- Some positive randomized trials, but small, short, few or inconsistent
- C
- Limited human evidence: single small trials, observational data or mixed results
- D
- Laboratory or animal evidence only; not shown in people
- X
- Well-designed human trials found no meaningful effect
The botanical finder ranks ingredients by these grades only. Safety, US regulatory status and quality are shown beside the ranking and never change it, because a well-studied ingredient can still be unsafe for some people.
How much each ingredient has been studied
Each ingredient also gets one evidence class. The class counts only studies of the ingredient taken on its own; trials of mixtures or multi-herb formulas do not count toward it. Trials by any route count, including injected, topical and inhaled forms; when the counted trials did not give the ingredient by mouth, the entry says so beside its class. Classes 1 to 3 describe studies in people, Class 4 studies in living animals, and Class 5 laboratory tests only.
- Class 1
- Well studied in people. A systematic review or meta-analysis pooling 5 or more randomized controlled trials of the ingredient alone, or 10 or more such trials.
- Class 2
- Moderately studied in people. 3 to 9 randomized controlled trials of the ingredient alone, or a systematic review pooling fewer than 5.
- Class 3
- Limited studies in people. 1 or 2 randomized controlled trials of the ingredient alone, or only non-randomized human studies such as open-label trials, cohorts or case series.
- Class 4
- Animal studies only. No published human study of the ingredient alone; at least one study in living animals (in vivo). Results in animals often do not carry over to people.
- Class 5
- Laboratory studies only. Only tests in cells, tissues, enzymes or test tubes (in vitro); no published animal or human study. Computer predictions alone do not qualify an ingredient for any class.
The class measures the amount and kind of research, not the result. A Class 1 ingredient can have consistent findings of no effect (grade X), and any class can carry serious safety warnings. The per-topic grades above say what the studies found; the safety section says what can go wrong.
The thresholds are this guide's editorial rule, not an external standard. They put systematic reviews of randomized trials at the top, as the Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine (OCEBM) 2011 Levels of Evidence do for treatment benefits (Level 1). Each entry states the review or trial count behind its class, with its source.
How each statement is checked
- Every statement carries its source, and the source was opened when the statement was written.
- A second, independent review re-opens every cited source and corrects or removes whatever the source does not support. In the October 2026 review this lowered grades where a single trial had been graded too high, corrected FDA notification counts and fixed wording that went beyond the source.
- FDA status comes only from FDA's published list of new dietary ingredient notifications, counted for each ingredient; the guide never calls an ingredient “FDA-approved” or “grandfathered”, because FDA approves neither.
- Cancer evaluations name the exact material IARC or the National Toxicology Program tested, which may differ from what is sold.
- Software checks reject pages with missing sources or forbidden wording (for example “cures” or “treats”) before anything is published.
Drafting and the source-by-source cross-checks are done with the help of AI research tools working from the opened sources; the rules above apply to every statement whoever drafted it. Each entry shows the date it was last fact-checked.
Report an error
If a statement does not match its source, or a newer source changes the picture, please write through the contact page with the page and the source. Corrections are made on the page and the fact-check date is updated.
Supplements A–Z · Botanical finder · Botanical encyclopedia (its own method section) · How to judge a supplement
Health information notice
These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Nothing on this site is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. The information is for general education only. It is not medical advice and does not replace advice, diagnosis or treatment from a qualified health professional, or any medication a clinician has prescribed.
Do not start, stop or change any medicine, supplement or herbal product because of something you read here. Talk to your doctor or pharmacist first, especially if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, have a medical condition, take any medicines, are preparing for surgery, or are caring for a child. Research findings, traditional uses and safety data are reported as their sources state them; they are not recommendations or claims about any product. If you think you may have a medical emergency, call your doctor or 911 at once.
EUTECNIQ Sciences sells no supplements or health products today and receives nothing from any product or ingredient mentioned on this site; any commercial interest it later has in an ingredient will be stated on that ingredient’s page.