EUTECNIQAtlas

Every page of EUTECNIQ on one mapArrow keys move through results · Enter opens · Esc closes

Supplements A–Z guide Pro preview — free while in preview Runs in your browser

Pro tools in free preview

Two editorial indices for all 264 A–Z entries and four calculators, each with its equation, assumptions and a worked example from a cited source.

The six tools

Index 1 · 264 entries

Evidence Strength Index

How much human research exists for an ingredient and how strongly it supports a studied use, from 0 to 100.

Open the index →
Index 2 · 264 entries

Quality-Risk Index

Documented adulteration, liver-injury category, carcinogen classification, conservation status and form diversity.

Open the index →
Process · ICH Q8(R2)

CQA and design-space explorer

Ethanol, temperature and time against phenolic content and DPPH activity in a published extraction model.

Open the explorer →
Stability · ICH Q1A(R2), Q1E

Shelf-life and stability calculator

Arrhenius fit of accelerated rate constants, extrapolated to storage temperature with its confidence interval.

Open the calculator →
Safety · agency values

Intake and margin of exposure

Daily intake against an upper limit, an ADI or a NOAEL from a cited agency list of 30 values.

Open the calculator →
Engineering · first principles

Spray-drying mass and energy balance

Evaporation capacity, feed rate, exhaust humidity and yield from air flow and temperatures.

Open the calculator →

Indices are editorial constructs. The two EUTECNIQ indices are this site's own summaries of sourced data, with published formulas and weights. They are not regulatory, clinical or safety measures, they do not rate products or brands, and a score does not say whether an ingredient works or is safe for any person.

Pro preview — free while in preview. No payment is connected and there is no account, price or paywall. If EUTECNIQ Pro launches, these tools may become part of it; the Pro page describes the plan. Join the Pro waiting list. Everything is calculated in your browser; nothing you enter is stored or sent. These tools do not give dosing advice. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This information is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.

Related tools: Vitamin unit converters, iodine and caffeine · Design space and Pareto optimization · Pharmacokinetics calculator · Toxicology and dose course

Index 1 Editorial index

EUTECNIQ Evidence Strength Index for all 264 A–Z entries

The index combines five numbers already on each A–Z page: the evidence class, the best grade, the share of topics graded C or X, the number of graded topics and the number of sources. Move the weights to see how much the ranking depends on them.

Index (0–100) and its five components, each scaled to 0–1ESI = 100 · Σ wi si / Σ wi
sclass = (5 − class)/4 · sgrade: A 1, B ⅔, C ⅓, D 0 · sconsistency = 1 − (nX + nC)/n · sbreadth = min(n, 6)/6 · ssources = min(nsrc, 12)/12

Interactive calculator Change the inputs and the result updates. An educational simulation with stated inputs.

Index of the ingredient–
Rank among 264–
Mean over 264–
Rank correlation with published weights (Spearman ρ)–

Component scores behind the index, one row per ingredientComputed from A–Z data
Inputs: the evidence class, graded evidence rows and source list of each A–Z entry (reviewed October 28–30, 2026). Darker cells score higher. Computed on this page from the same inputs as the published values.
Weights, scales and why they were chosen
Components of the Evidence Strength Index
ComponentInput on the A–Z pageScaleWeightRationale
Evidence classClass 1–5 from the count of randomized trials of the ingredient alone1 → 1.00, 2 → 0.75, 3 → 0.50, 4 → 0.25, 5 → 035The only input that counts trials, and the count is stated with its source on each page; it carries the largest weight.
Best gradeHighest of A, B, C, D across graded topicsA 1, B ⅔, C ⅓, D 0; X does not count as supportive25Says whether at least one studied use has consistent trial support. Equal steps because the grades are ordered categories.
ConsistencyShare of topics graded C (limited) or X (no meaningful effect)1 − share20An ingredient studied often but mostly with limited or null results should not score like one with consistent findings.
Graded topicsNumber of evidence rowsmin(n, 6)/6; 6 is the most rows the A–Z schema asks for10Breadth of human study. Low weight, because more topics is not stronger evidence.
SourcesNumber of cited sourcesmin(nsrc, 12)/12; the 90th percentile across entries is 1210Documentation depth. Low weight, because it measures how much was cited, not what it found.

The weights are editorial choices, not estimates. The rank correlation readout shows how much a different choice changes the ordering. A low index can mean little research or mostly null results; it does not mean an ingredient is unsafe, and a high index does not mean it will have an effect for a given person.

Worked example: the published weights applied to one entry
Ashwagandha: component scores and their contribution (index 71.3, rank 88 of 264)
ComponentInputScore sWeight w100·w·s/Σw
Evidence classClass 11.0003535.0
Best gradebest grade B0.6672516.7
Consistency3 of 5 topics graded C or X0.400208.0
Graded topics5 graded topics0.833108.3
Sources4 sources0.333103.3
Index10071.3

Ashwagandha in the A–Z guide lists the sources behind each input.

Inputs from the A–Z entry linked in the table; the cited sources are listed on that page.

All 264 entries

Select a column heading to sort. The index column updates with the weights above.

Evidence Strength Index and its inputs for every A–Z entry
Whey proteinAmino acid and protein1A50%995.8
Inulin and FOSOther1A617%994.2
Beta-glucan (oat and barley)Other1A40%792.5
Saccharomyces boulardiiProbiotic1A425%1190.8
Sodium (electrolytes)Mineral1A30%589.2
CaffeineOther1A20%587.5
PsylliumBotanical1A20%587.5
IronMineral1A520%286.0
Lactiplantibacillus plantarum 299vProbiotic1B520%1286.0
Notoginseng (san qi)Botanical1B30%1185.8
MelatoninOther1A633%285.0
Lacticaseibacillus rhamnosus GG (LGG)Probiotic1B633%1184.2
Alpha-lipoic acidOther1B30%984.2
LactoferrinAmino acid and protein1B40%784.2
Multivitamin/mineral supplementsOther1A650%483.3
AmlaBotanical1B30%782.5
Omega-3 fatty acidsFatty acid1A650%382.5
Plant sterols and stanolsOther1A450%782.5
CranberryBotanical1A650%281.7
Beetroot juice (dietary nitrate)Other1B30%681.7
PurslaneBotanical1B650%1281.7
Black seedBotanical1B425%980.8
Lactotripeptides (IPP and VPP)Amino acid and protein1B30%580.8
Bitter melonBotanical1B650%1080.0
Damask roseBotanical1B425%880.0
Grape seed extractBotanical1B425%880.0
Hibiscus (roselle)Botanical1B333%1280.0
SaffronBotanical1B425%880.0
Undenatured type II collagenAmino acid and protein1B650%1080.0
Red cloverBotanical1B540%979.5
American ginsengBotanical1B333%1179.2
Folate (folic acid)Vitamin1A667%379.2
GlucomannanOther1A475%979.2
Cocoa flavanolsOther1B425%779.2
HMB (beta-hydroxy-beta-methylbutyrate)Other1B425%779.2
ChlorellaMarine and algae1B20%478.3
Garcinia cambogiaBotanical1B650%878.3
Limosilactobacillus reuteri DSM 17938Probiotic1B667%1578.3
Red yeast riceOther1A367%878.3
Resistant starchOther1B425%678.3
SafflowerBotanical1B450%1278.3
Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis BB-12Probiotic1B560%1678.0
Betaine (trimethylglycine)Other1B450%1177.5
L-carnitineAmino acid and protein1B633%377.5
QuercetinOther1B333%977.5
SpirulinaMarine and algae1B333%977.5
Soy isoflavonesOther1B450%1076.7
CreatineAmino acid and protein1A250%375.8
HesperidinOther1B450%975.8
Linoleic acidFatty acid1A475%575.8
Pelargonium sidoidesBotanical1B333%775.8
PomegranateBotanical1B450%975.8
Stinging nettleBotanical1B450%975.8
Vitamin CVitamin1A683%375.8
BacopaBotanical1B450%875.0
Conjugated linoleic acid (CLA)Fatty acid1B333%675.0
FennelBotanical1B450%875.0
Galactooligosaccharides (GOS)Other1B683%1375.0
KavaBotanical1B250%1675.0
L-theanineAmino acid and protein1B333%675.0
MSM (methylsulfonylmethane)Other1B683%1675.0
Niacin (vitamin B3)Vitamin1A250%275.0
St. John's wortBotanical1A475%475.0
TaurineAmino acid and protein1B333%675.0
MCT oil (medium-chain triglycerides)Fatty acid1B560%874.7
PropolisOther1B667%774.2
L-arginineAmino acid and protein1B450%774.2
White mulberry leafBotanical1B560%773.8
Branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs)Amino acid and protein1B333%473.3
Collagen peptidesAmino acid and protein1B450%673.3
L-citrullineAmino acid and protein1B450%673.3
Lemon balmBotanical1B450%673.3
Palmitoylethanolamide (PEA)Other1B450%673.3
ProbioticsProbiotic1B650%273.3
ShatavariBotanical1B367%1573.3
Vitamin AVitamin1A367%273.3
Escherichia coli Nissle 1917 (EcN)Probiotic2B540%2173.2
BromelainOther1B560%673.0
Kelp and seaweedMarine and algae1B250%972.5
Prickly pearBotanical1B683%972.5
ZincMineral1B650%172.5
Chasteberry (vitex)Botanical1B560%572.2
Argan oilFatty acid1B367%1071.7
CalciumMineral1B667%471.7
BerberineOther1B450%471.7
Manuka honeyOther1B683%871.7
TribulusBotanical1B475%1071.7
AshwagandhaBotanical1B560%471.3
Sangre de gradoBotanical2B333%1271.2
CuminBotanical1B475%970.8
Devil's clawBotanical1B367%970.8
Royal jellyOther1B683%770.8
AndrographisBotanical1B580%870.7
Algal oil (DHA and EPA)Fatty acid1B250%670.0
AstaxanthinMarine and algae1B367%870.0
Citicoline (CDP-choline)Other1B367%870.0
European mistletoeBotanical1B475%870.0
L-glutamineAmino acid and protein1B475%870.0
MagnesiumMineral1B450%270.0
SAMe (S-adenosyl-L-methionine)Amino acid and protein1B475%870.0
PotassiumMineral1B560%269.7
Bacillus coagulans (Heyndrickxia coagulans)Probiotic2B667%2269.6
SumacBotanical1B367%769.2
ShiitakeMushroom1B475%769.2
Krill oilFatty acid1B367%668.3
N-acetylcysteine (NAC)Amino acid and protein1B475%668.3
SulforaphaneOther1B475%668.3
Tart cherryBotanical1B475%668.3
TocotrienolsVitamin1B367%668.3
Turmeric (and curcumin)Botanical1B580%568.2
Beta-alanineAmino acid and protein1B250%367.5
MoringaBotanical1B475%567.5
Myo-inositolOther1B475%567.5
NattokinaseOther1B367%567.5
Asian ginsengBotanical1B580%467.3
GarlicBotanical1B580%467.3
GingerBotanical1B580%467.3
GymnemaBotanical2B450%967.1
Pantothenic acid (vitamin B5)Vitamin2B20%167.1
Green teaBotanical1B475%466.7
HawthornBotanical1B475%466.7
LavenderBotanical1B475%466.7
Turkey tailMushroom1B475%466.7
Vitamin DVitamin1B683%266.7
Rose hipBotanical2B683%1266.2
Peppermint oilBotanical1B475%365.8
SeleniumMineral1B475%365.8
ChromiumMineral1B580%265.7
Lutein and zeaxanthinOther2B683%1165.4
MangosteenBotanical2B683%1165.4
Riboflavin (vitamin B2)Vitamin1B367%265.0
Tongkat aliBotanical2B475%1163.8
ArjunaBotanical1C7100%1463.3
BenfotiamineVitamin1C6100%1263.3
CalendulaBotanical1C6100%1963.3
HaritakiBotanical1C6100%1463.3
Lacticaseibacillus paracasei strain Shirota (LcS)Probiotic1C6100%2363.3
GlutathioneAmino acid and protein2B580%962.8
Sea buckthornBotanical2B580%962.8
Holy basilBotanical1C6100%1162.5
CordycepsMushroom1C6100%1061.7
Streptococcus salivarius K12Probiotic1C5100%1461.7
Vitamin B6Vitamin2B560%260.9
CissusBotanical1C6100%960.8
GLA oils (borage and blackcurrant seed oil)Fatty acid2B367%760.4
Eleuthero (Siberian ginseng)Botanical1C4100%1660.0
Nicotinamide ribosideVitamin1C4100%1560.0
ResveratrolOther1C683%460.0
Hyaluronic acid (oral)Other2B367%659.6
Black gingerBotanical1C5100%959.2
Olive leaf extractBotanical1C5100%959.2
Carnosine (L-carnosine)Amino acid and protein2B475%558.8
Methylfolate (L-5-MTHF)Vitamin2B250%358.8
BoswelliaBotanical2B580%458.6
GojiBotanical1C4100%1058.3
HopsBotanical1C3100%1458.3
ButterburBotanical2B475%357.1
ElderberryBotanical2B367%357.1
Aloe veraBotanical1C5100%656.7
AstragalusBotanical1C4100%856.7
Gotu kolaBotanical1C4100%856.7
GuggulBotanical1C4100%856.7
ReishiMushroom1C4100%856.7
Tea tree oilBotanical1C6100%456.7
GuaranaBotanical1C3100%955.8
Yerba mateBotanical1C3100%955.8
NeemBotanical2C475%1155.4
NoniBotanical2C475%1155.4
RooibosBotanical2C580%1055.2
Arachidonic acidFatty acid1C4100%655.0
Coenzyme Q10Other1C5100%455.0
DanshenBotanical1C3100%855.0
GinkgoBotanical1C5100%455.0
SteviaBotanical1C3100%855.0
5-HTP (5-hydroxytryptophan)Amino acid and protein2C7100%1654.6
GuduchiBotanical2C250%854.6
PerillaBotanical2C7100%1354.6
SpearmintBotanical2C7100%1254.6
Aronia (black chokeberry)Botanical1C3100%754.2
Bitter orangeBotanical1C5100%354.2
Black cohoshBotanical1C4100%554.2
CholineOther1C5100%354.2
Glucosamine and chondroitinOther1C5100%354.2
ValerianBotanical1C4100%554.2
Vitamin EVitamin1C5100%253.3
ChamomileBotanical1C4100%453.3
EchinaceaBotanical1C4100%453.3
Evening primrose oilFatty acid1C4100%453.3
Flaxseed and flaxseed oilBotanical1C4100%453.3
Licorice rootBotanical1C4100%453.3
Milk thistleBotanical1C4100%453.3
Saw palmettoBotanical1C4100%453.3
BilberryBotanical2C5100%1152.1
PhosphatidylserineOther2C5100%1152.1
Vitamin K2 (menaquinone-7)Vitamin2C5100%1152.1
FenugreekBotanical1C3100%451.7
RhodiolaBotanical1C3100%451.7
Vitamin B12Vitamin1C4100%251.7
Cat's clawBotanical2C4100%1351.2
Ecklonia cavaMarine and algae2C5100%1051.2
JujubeBotanical2C4100%1451.2
Mastic gumBotanical2C5100%1051.2
SageBotanical2C6100%851.2
Sweet wormwoodBotanical2C4100%1251.2
EphedraBotanical3B250%450.8
NMN (nicotinamide mononucleotide)Other1C3100%350.8
ArnicaBotanical2C4100%1150.4
FucoidanMarine and algae2C6100%750.4
LycopeneOther2C5100%950.4
UbiquinolOther2C5100%950.4
IodineMineral1C3100%250.0
AçaíBotanical2C4100%1049.6
BladderwrackMarine and algae2C3100%1349.6
Carrageenan and agarMarine and algae2C3100%1349.6
D-riboseOther2C4100%1049.6
Kudzu rootBotanical2C4100%1049.6
SchisandraBotanical2C5100%849.6
CinnamonBotanical1C2100%349.2
DunaliellaMarine and algae2C3100%1148.8
MacaBotanical2C4100%948.8
RosemaryBotanical2C4100%948.8
Velvet bean (Mucuna)Botanical2C4100%948.8
Costus rootBotanical3C250%1148.3
Java turmericBotanical3C450%748.3
Vitamin KVitamin1C2100%248.3
KannaBotanical2C4100%847.9
Lion's maneMushroom2C4100%847.9
MaitakeMushroom2C4100%847.9
BuchuBotanical3C333%447.5
SennaBotanical2C3100%947.1
BPC-157Amino acid and protein3C560%546.3
Butcher's broomBotanical2C4100%646.2
L-tryptophanAmino acid and protein2C3100%846.2
PQQ (pyrroloquinoline quinone)Other2C4100%646.2
ThymeBotanical2C2100%1046.2
GuayusaBotanical2C2100%945.4
SpermidineOther2C3100%745.4
Kutki (Picrorhiza)Botanical3C367%945.0
Pau d'arcoBotanical3C475%945.0
FeverfewBotanical2C4100%444.6
PassionflowerBotanical2C3100%644.6
HoneybushBotanical3C367%743.3
Akkermansia muciniphila (pasteurized)Probiotic3C5100%1143.3
BoronMineral2C3100%442.9
GoldensealBotanical3C250%442.5
Sutherlandia (cancer bush)Botanical3C367%642.5
Thiamin (vitamin B1)Vitamin2C4100%142.1
CopperMineral2C2100%441.2
SerrapeptaseOther2C2100%441.2
Pumpkin seedBotanical3C4100%940.0
BiotinVitamin2C2100%239.6
California poppyBotanical3C3100%1039.2
Dong quaiBotanical3C3100%1039.2
ChagaMushroom4D30%638.8
AsafoetidaBotanical3C2100%1138.3
Baikal skullcapBotanical3C3100%938.3
YohimbeBotanical4D20%737.9
Jatamansi (spikenard)Botanical3C2100%1037.5
Sea mossMarine and algae4D20%637.1
Bee pollenOther3C2100%936.7
He shou wu (fo-ti)Botanical3C2100%936.7
Gentian rootBotanical3C3100%535.0
ManganeseMineral3C2100%331.7
MolybdenumMineral3C1100%128.3
Method, assumptions and limits: Evidence Strength Index
What it calculates
A weighted mean of five component scores between 0 and 1, multiplied by 100.
Inputs
The evidence class (Class 1–5, counted from randomized trials of the ingredient alone), the grade of each evidence row (A, B, C, D or X) and the source list of each A–Z entry, as published on October 28–30, 2026.
Assumptions
Grades and classes are ordinal and are scored in equal steps. Every topic counts equally, whatever its importance to a reader.
What it does not establish
Effect sizes, trial quality beyond the grade, relevance to a particular person, or safety. It is not a GRADE certainty rating.
Verification
One script computes all 264 scores; the page recomputes them in your browser from the same component values; and a separate pandas and SciPy script recomputes selected scores, ranks, means and rank correlations for the automated numerical test.
Index 2 Editorial index

EUTECNIQ Quality-Risk Index from the finder's safety and supply data

Five documented signals from each ingredient's finder file: published adulteration reports, the NIH LiverTox likelihood category, an IARC or NTP evaluation of the material itself, IUCN or CITES status, and the number of FDA new dietary ingredient (NDI) notifications naming it. Higher means more documented quality and sourcing concerns to check.

Index (0–100) and its five components, each scaled to 0–1QRI = 100 · Σ wi si / Σ wi
sadulteration = min(n, 3)/3 · sliver: LiverTox A 1, B 0.75, C 0.5, D 0.25, E or none 0 · scarcinogen = max(IARC 1 → 1, 2A → 0.75, 2B → 0.5, 3 → 0; NTP clear → 0.5, some → 0.25) · sconservation = max(IUCN CR 1, EN 0.75, VU 0.5, NT 0.25; CITES I 1, II 0.5, III 0.25) · sforms = min(nNDI, 10)/10

Interactive calculator Change the inputs and the result updates. An educational simulation with stated inputs.

Index of the ingredient–
Rank among 264–
Mean over 264–
Rank correlation with published weights (Spearman ρ)–

Documented signals behind the index, one row per ingredientComputed from finder data
Inputs (checked October 29, 2026): BAPP adulteration bulletins and peer-reviewed adulteration studies; NIH LiverTox; IARC Monographs list of classifications; NTP technical reports; IUCN Red List via the GBIF species API; CITES Species+; FDA's published NDI notification list dated July 9, 2026.
Weights, scales and why they were chosen
Components of the Quality-Risk Index
ComponentInput in the finder fileScaleWeightRationale
AdulterationNumber of adulteration rows (BAPP bulletins or peer-reviewed studies)min(n, 3)/330Documented substitution is the most direct quality signal for identity testing; capped because a third bulletin adds less than the first.
Liver injuryLiverTox likelihood category of the ingredient itselfA 1, B 0.75, C 0.5, D 0.25, E or no chapter 025LiverTox's ordered categories run from “well known” (A, more than 50 cases) to “unlikely” (E). High-dose categories (for example A[HD]) are scored as their letter.
Carcinogen evaluationIARC group or NTP conclusion for the material as soldIARC 1 → 1, 2A → 0.75, 2B → 0.5, 3 → 0; NTP clear → 0.5, some → 0.25; the higher counts20NTP conclusions rest on rodent studies alone, so they are scored no higher than IARC Group 2B; only the higher of the two scores counts.
ConservationIUCN Red List category or CITES appendix of the source speciesCR 1, EN 0.75, VU 0.5, NT 0.25; CITES I 1, II 0.5, III 0.25; the higher counts15Scarce, trade-controlled species face supply pressure and permit requirements.
Form diversityNDI notifications naming the ingredient or a form of itmin(n, 10)/1010Each notification describes one firm's ingredient and conditions of use, so many notifications mean one label name can cover materially different materials. It is not a safety signal and says nothing about FDA's response.

An index of 0 means none of the five signals was found in the sources checked; it is not evidence of safety or quality. The index says nothing about a particular product, which needs its own certificate of analysis.

How each signal was coded, with the sentence it came from

Signals are read from the finder text by fixed rules: a LiverTox letter after “likelihood score” or “likelihood category”; an IARC group or NTP conclusion only when the sentence concerns the ingredient itself, not a constituent, contaminant, substitute or another chemical form; IUCN and CITES status of the source species. Rows the rules cannot decide are settled by the overrides listed last.

Every non-zero LiverTox, carcinogen and conservation coding and every override
IngredientComponentCoded asSentence in the finder file
Aloe veraLiverToxB → 0.75LiverTox likelihood score B: likely but rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury (chapter last updated May 24, 2022).
Aloe veraIARC or NTPIARC Group 2B → 0.50IARC: Aloe vera, whole leaf extract, Group 2B (possibly carcinogenic to humans), IARC Monographs Volume 108 (2016). The classification names whole leaf extract, not the clear inner-leaf gel.
American ginsengIUCN or CITESCITES Appendix II → 0.50CITES Appendix II (current listing effective 12 June 2013); annotation #3 covers whole and sliced roots and parts of roots, excluding manufactured parts or derivatives such as powders, pills, extracts, tonics, teas and …
Argan oilIUCN or CITESIUCN VU → 0.50IUCN Red List: Vulnerable (VU), via GBIF species API, retrieved 2026-10-29 (assessed under the accepted name Sideroxylon spinosum).
AshwagandhaLiverToxB → 0.75LiverTox likelihood score B: likely cause of clinically apparent liver injury (chapter last updated December 3, 2024). Onset is 2 to 12 weeks after starting, usually cholestatic or mixed, with jaundice and itching; most cases …
Asian ginsengIUCN or CITESIUCN CR → 1.00IUCN Red List: Critically Endangered (CR), via GBIF species API, retrieved 2026-10-29.
Black cohoshLiverToxA → 1.00LiverTox likelihood score A: products sold as black cohosh are well established causes of clinically apparent liver injury, but the specific ingredient or component responsible is unclear (chapter last updated April 15, 2025). …
BuchuLiverToxD → 0.25LiverTox likelihood score D (possible, rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury), chapter updated March 3, 2023: a single case of acute hepatitis in a patient taking both buchu and rooibos tea; little evidence that buchu …
ButterburLiverToxC → 0.50LiverTox likelihood score C: probable cause of clinically apparent liver injury, possibly caused by contaminants (chapter last updated February 18, 2019). Preparations processed to remove pyrrolizidine alkaloids do not appear …
CinnamonLiverToxD → 0.25NIH LiverTox (last update July 1, 2026): likelihood score D, "possible rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury". LiverTox states the mechanism by which cinnamon might cause liver injury is not known, possibly related to …
CinnamonIUCN or CITESIUCN VU → 0.50IUCN Red List: Vulnerable (VU), via GBIF species API, retrieved 2026-10-29 (Cinnamomum verum J.Presl).
CopperLiverToxA → 1.00NIH LiverTox (Copper; references updated 30 October 2017): likelihood score A[HD], "well known cause of acute and chronic liver injury but only when taken in high doses".
CordycepsIUCN or CITESIUCN VU → 0.50IUCN Red List: Vulnerable (VU), via GBIF species API, retrieved 2026-10-29 (Ophiocordyceps sinensis).
Costus rootIUCN or CITESIUCN CR → 1.00IUCN Red List: Critically Endangered (CR) (assessed under the name Saussurea costus), via GBIF species API, retrieved 2026-10-29.
EchinaceaLiverToxD → 0.25LiverTox likelihood score D: possible rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury (chapter last updated April 10, 2019).
Garcinia cambogiaLiverToxB → 0.75LiverTox likelihood score B: likely rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury (chapter last updated February 13, 2019). Onset typically 1 to 4 weeks (sometimes 3 to 12 months) after starting; hepatocellular pattern; …
GinkgoIARC or NTPIARC Group 2B → 0.50IARC Group 2B (possibly carcinogenic to humans): Ginkgo biloba extract, IARC Monographs Volume 108 (2016).
GinkgoIUCN or CITESIUCN EN → 0.75IUCN Red List: Endangered (EN), via GBIF species API, retrieved 2026-10-29
Glucosamine and chondroitinLiverToxD → 0.25LiverTox likelihood score D for glucosamine: possible rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury (chapter last updated March 12, 2018); no separate score is given for chondroitin.
GoldensealIARC or NTPIARC Group 2B → 0.50IARC: goldenseal root powder is classified in Group 2B (possibly carcinogenic to humans), IARC Monographs Volume 108 (2016).
GoldensealIUCN or CITESIUCN VU → 0.50IUCN Red List: Vulnerable (VU), via GBIF species API, retrieved 2026-10-29.
Gotu kolaLiverToxC → 0.50LiverTox likelihood score C: probable rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury. Cases (including three Argentinian women using it for weight loss) had onset at 3 to 8 weeks, hepatocellular injury and full recovery 1 to 2 …
Green teaLiverToxA → 1.00LiverTox likelihood score A (well established cause of clinically apparent liver injury), chapter last updated November 20, 2020.
GuduchiLiverToxA → 1.00LiverTox likelihood score A (well-established cause of clinically apparent liver injury); more than 50 cases since 2017, several fatal, mostly in people with preexisting liver disease (chapter updated June 27, 2025).
GuggulIUCN or CITESIUCN CR → 1.00IUCN Red List: Critically Endangered (CR), via GBIF species API, retrieved 2026-10-29
GymnemaLiverToxD → 0.25LiverTox likelihood score D: possible rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury. Small, short trials showed no changes in ALT, AST, GGT or bilirubin; effects of long-term use and higher doses have not been assessed in …
He shou wu (fo-ti)LiverToxA → 1.00LiverTox likelihood category A (well-established cause of clinically apparent liver injury); hepatocellular or mixed injury within days to 6 months; up to 10% of clinically apparent cases fatal or requiring urgent transplant …
HoneybushIUCN or CITESIUCN NT → 0.25Cyclopia genistoides — IUCN Red List: Near Threatened (NT), via GBIF species API, retrieved 2026-10-29.
IronLiverToxA → 1.00LiverTox likelihood score A[H]: a well established cause of clinically apparent acute and chronic liver injury when given in high doses; typical replacement doses of oral iron have not been linked convincingly to serum enzyme …
Jatamansi (spikenard)IUCN or CITESIUCN CR → 1.00IUCN Red List: Critically Endangered (CR), via GBIF species API, retrieved 2026-10-29.
KavaLiverToxA → 1.00LiverTox likelihood score A (well known cause of clinically apparent liver injury), chapter last updated April 10, 2018.
KavaIARC or NTPIARC Group 2B → 0.50IARC: kava extract is classified in Group 2B (possibly carcinogenic to humans), IARC Monographs Volume 108 (2016).
Kutki (Picrorhiza)IUCN or CITESIUCN EN → 0.75IUCN Red List: Endangered (EN), via GBIF species API, retrieved 2026-10-29.
MoringaLiverToxD → 0.25LiverTox likelihood score D: possible rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury. Not linked to serum enzyme elevations in trials; a single case of acute anicteric hepatitis from Brazil has been published (chapter updated …
Niacin (vitamin B3)LiverToxA → 1.00LiverTox likelihood score A[HD]: well known cause of clinically apparent liver injury when given in high doses (chapter last updated July 9, 2020).
NoniLiverToxC → 0.50LiverTox likelihood category C (probable rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury); acute hepatocellular hepatitis with 2 to 8 weeks latency in isolated case reports (chapter updated March 28, 2020).
Pau d'arcoIUCN or CITESCITES Appendix II → 0.50CITES Appendix II: Handroanthus spp. listed at CoP19 (November 2022), in effect since 25 November 2024, annotation #17: logs, sawn wood, veneer sheets, plywood and transformed wood.
QuercetinIARC or NTPNTP some evidence → 0.25NTP TR-409 (quercetin in feed at 1,000, 10,000 or 40,000 ppm for 2 years, F344/N rats): some evidence of carcinogenic activity in male rats, based on increased renal tubule cell adenomas; no evidence in female rats.
Red yeast riceLiverToxC → 0.50LiverTox (last update June 4, 2018): likelihood score C, a probable rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury. Prospective controlled trials showed no serum enzyme elevations or clinically apparent liver injury, but …
ReishiLiverToxD → 0.25LiverTox likelihood score D (possible rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury) (chapter last updated October 5, 2024).
Saw palmettoLiverToxD → 0.25LiverTox likelihood score D: possible, rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury (chapter last updated April 2, 2020).
SennaLiverToxD → 0.25LiverTox likelihood score D (possible rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury), chapter updated April 1, 2020: rare hepatocellular injury after high doses over 3 to 5 months, usually resolving after stopping; …
SpirulinaLiverToxD → 0.25LiverTox likelihood score D: possible rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury (chapter last updated April 10, 2019). LiverTox notes spirulina can be contaminated with other blue-green algae that produce toxins …
Tongkat aliLiverToxD → 0.25LiverTox likelihood score D (possible rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury); reported injury was self-limited and appeared immunologically mediated (chapter updated October 18, 2024).
Turmeric (and curcumin)LiverToxA → 1.00LiverTox likelihood score A (recently established as a well-documented cause of clinically apparent liver injury), chapter updated 2025-06-16. Latency typically 1 to 4 months; hepatocellular pattern; HLA-B*35:01 found in over …
ValerianLiverToxC → 0.50LiverTox likelihood score C (probable rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury), chapter updated 2020-04-05. Published cases usually involved valerian combined with other botanicals; latency 3 to 12 weeks; usually mild …
Vitamin ALiverToxA → 1.00LiverTox likelihood score A[H] (well established cause of liver injury when used in high doses), chapter updated 2020-11-04. Normal doses are not associated with liver injury or liver test abnormalities; higher doses …
Yerba mateLiverToxD → 0.25LiverTox likelihood score D: possible but rare cause of clinically apparent liver injury. One well-described case (a 21-year-old man after 4 months of daily drinking) resolved within 2 months of stopping (chapter updated …
Yerba mateIUCN or CITESIUCN NT → 0.25IUCN Red List: Near Threatened (NT), via GBIF species API, retrieved 2026-10-29.
Sweet wormwoodLiverToxRule override → 0.00The LiverTox score D is given to artemisinin derivatives (drugs), not to the herb.
Baikal skullcapLiverToxRule override → 0.00The LiverTox category B belongs to American skullcap, a different species.
Beetroot juice (dietary nitrate)IARC or NTPRule override → 0.00IARC Group 2A applies to ingested nitrate or nitrite under conditions that result in endogenous nitrosation, an exposure circumstance; IARC has no entry for beetroot.
Carrageenan and agarIARC or NTPRule override → 0.00Native carrageenan, the material in this entry, is IARC Group 3; the Group 2B listing is for degraded carrageenan (poligeenan), a different material.
ChromiumIARC or NTPRule override → 0.00Supplements contain trivalent chromium, IARC Group 3; the Group 1 listing is for chromium(VI) compounds.
MolybdenumIARC or NTPRule override → 0.00IARC and NTP evaluated molybdenum trioxide, which is not among the supplement forms NIH ODS lists.
Soy isoflavonesIARC or NTPRule override → 0.00NTP TR-545 tested genistein, one of the isoflavones in the ingredient, as a pure compound.
Yerba mateIARC or NTPRule override → 0.00Mate that is not very hot is IARC Group 3; Group 2A applies to drinking very hot beverages above 65 °C, an exposure circumstance.
Worked example: the published weights applied to one entry
Kava: component scores and their contribution (index 67.0, rank 1 of 264)
ComponentInputScore sWeight w100·w·s/Σw
Adulteration reports3 rows1.0003030.0
LiverTox categorycategory A1.0002525.0
IARC or NTPIARC Group 2B0.5002010.0
IUCN or CITES–0.000150.0
NDI notifications2 notifications0.200102.0
Index10067.0

Kava in the A–Z guide lists the sources behind each input.

All 264 entries

Select a column heading to sort. The index column updates with the weights above.

Quality-Risk Index and its inputs for every A–Z entry
Kava3AIARC Group 2B–267.0
Turmeric (and curcumin)3A––661.0
Green tea2A––449.0
Black cohosh2A––045.0
Asian ginseng2E–IUCN CR843.0
Ginkgo2EIARC Group 2BIUCN EN142.2
Aloe vera1BIARC Group 2B–139.8
Garcinia cambogia1B––1038.8
Saw palmetto3D––238.2
Goldenseal2–IARC Group 2BIUCN VU037.5
Guduchi1A––237.0
He shou wu (fo-ti)1A––237.0
Reishi2D––1536.2
Cordyceps2E–IUCN VU835.5
Costus root2––IUCN CR035.0
Iron0A––1235.0
Niacin (vitamin B3)0A––1235.0
Bilberry3E––232.0
Copper0A––732.0
5-HTP (5-hydroxytryptophan)3–––131.0
Milk thistle3E––131.0
Probiotics2–––7430.0
Tea tree oil3–––030.0
Vitamin A0A––530.0
Ashwagandha1B––129.8
Cinnamon1D–IUCN VU528.8
Tongkat ali2D––127.2
Echinacea2D––026.2
Red yeast rice1C––325.5
Jatamansi (spikenard)1––IUCN CR025.0
Butterbur1C––123.5
Bitter orange2–––323.0
Melatonin2E––323.0
Cranberry2E––222.0
Kutki (Picrorhiza)1––IUCN EN021.2
L-tryptophan2–––121.0
Lavender2E––121.0
Saffron2–––121.0
St. John's wort2E––121.0
Glucosamine and chondroitin1D––420.2
Damask rose2–––020.0
Feverfew2–––020.0
Maca2E––020.0
Yohimbe2E––020.0
American ginseng1E–CITES Appendix II219.5
Argan oil1––IUCN VU118.5
Pau d'arco1––CITES Appendix II017.5
Hawthorn1E––717.0
Buchu1D––016.2
Guggul0––IUCN CR015.0
Rhodiola1–––414.0
Noni0C––113.5
Valerian0C––113.5
Eleuthero (Siberian ginseng)1–––313.0
Notoginseng (san qi)1–––313.0
Pomegranate1–––313.0
Soy isoflavones1–––313.0
Gotu kola0C––012.5
Bacopa1E––212.0
Black seed1E––212.0
Danshen1–––212.0
Evening primrose oil1–––212.0
Grape seed extract1E––111.0
Maitake1–––111.0
Moringa0D––410.2
Algal oil (DHA and EPA)0–––1010.0
Arnica1E––010.0
Astaxanthin0–––1810.0
Bee pollen1E––010.0
Berberine1E––010.0
Boswellia1E––010.0
Cat's claw1–––010.0
Chasteberry (vitex)1E––010.0
Creatine0–––1210.0
Elderberry1–––010.0
Folate (folic acid)0E––1110.0
Gentian root1–––010.0
Holy basil1–––010.0
Lacticaseibacillus rhamnosus GG (LGG)1–––010.0
Licorice root0E––1110.0
Magnesium0–––1510.0
Manuka honey1–––010.0
NMN (nicotinamide mononucleotide)0–––1110.0
Omega-3 fatty acids0E––3010.0
Sage1–––010.0
SAMe (S-adenosyl-L-methionine)0–––1110.0
Sangre de grado1E––010.0
Sea buckthorn0–––1710.0
Selenium0–––1410.0
Sumac1–––010.0
Thiamin (vitamin B1)0E––2010.0
Vitamin B120E––1510.0
Vitamin B60E––1310.0
Vitamin C0E––1110.0
Vitamin E0E––1010.0
Yerba mate0D–IUCN NT010.0
Zinc0E––1310.0
Senna0D––39.2
Collagen peptides0–––99.0
Methylfolate (L-5-MTHF)0–––99.0
Plant sterols and stanols0–––99.0
Spirulina0D––28.2
Astragalus0E––88.0
Choline0–––88.0
Riboflavin (vitamin B2)0–––88.0
Benfotiamine0–––77.0
Vitamin D0E––77.0
Gymnema0D––06.2
L-arginine0–––66.0
Nicotinamide riboside0–––66.0
Calcium0–––55.0
Chromium0–––55.0
Kelp and seaweed0E––55.0
Pantothenic acid (vitamin B5)0–––55.0
PQQ (pyrroloquinoline quinone)0–––55.0
Quercetin0ENTP some evidence–05.0
Turkey tail0–––55.0
Vitamin K0E––55.0
Akkermansia muciniphila (pasteurized)0–––44.0
Chamomile0E––44.0
Fenugreek0E––44.0
Garlic0–––44.0
Glutathione0–––44.0
Krill oil0E––44.0
Manganese0–––44.0
Resveratrol0–––44.0
Honeybush0––IUCN NT03.8
Amla0–––33.0
Açaí0–––33.0
Bitter melon0E––33.0
Conjugated linoleic acid (CLA)0–––33.0
Dong quai0–––33.0
Ecklonia cava0–––33.0
Flaxseed and flaxseed oil0–––33.0
Ginger0E––33.0
Haritaki0–––33.0
Hesperidin0–––33.0
Iodine0–––33.0
Jujube0–––33.0
L-carnitine0–––33.0
Lutein and zeaxanthin0–––33.0
Potassium0–––33.0
Rosemary0–––33.0
Serrapeptase0–––33.0
Spermidine0–––33.0
Sutherlandia (cancer bush)0–––33.0
Alpha-lipoic acid0E––22.0
Biotin0E––22.0
Carnosine (L-carnosine)0–––22.0
Coenzyme Q100E––22.0
D-ribose0–––22.0
Fucoidan0–––22.0
Hyaluronic acid (oral)0–––22.0
L-glutamine0–––22.0
L-theanine0–––22.0
Mangosteen0–––22.0
Mastic gum0–––22.0
Nattokinase0–––22.0
Palmitoylethanolamide (PEA)0–––22.0
Peppermint oil0–––22.0
Propolis0E––22.0
Psyllium0–––22.0
Red clover0–––22.0
Saccharomyces boulardii0–––22.0
Safflower0–––22.0
Shiitake0–––22.0
Stevia0–––22.0
Sweet wormwood0–––22.0
Ubiquinol0E––22.0
Undenatured type II collagen0–––22.0
White mulberry leaf0–––22.0
Baikal skullcap0–––11.0
Beta-alanine0–––11.0
Boron0–––11.0
Bromelain0E––11.0
Calendula0–––11.0
Chaga0–––11.0
Cissus0–––11.0
Cumin0–––11.0
Dunaliella0–––11.0
Escherichia coli Nissle 1917 (EcN)0–––11.0
Galactooligosaccharides (GOS)0–––11.0
HMB (beta-hydroxy-beta-methylbutyrate)0–––11.0
Hops0E––11.0
Inulin and FOS0–––11.0
Kanna0–––11.0
Lactoferrin0–––11.0
Lion's mane0–––11.0
Molybdenum0–––11.0
Multivitamin/mineral supplements0–––11.0
N-acetylcysteine (NAC)0E––11.0
Passionflower0–––11.0
Royal jelly0–––11.0
Schisandra0–––11.0
Shatavari0–––11.0
Sodium (electrolytes)0–––11.0
Tocotrienols0–––11.0
Tribulus0E––11.0
Andrographis0–––00.0
Arachidonic acid0–––00.0
Arjuna0–––00.0
Aronia (black chokeberry)0–––00.0
Asafoetida0–––00.0
Bacillus coagulans (Heyndrickxia coagulans)0–––00.0
Beetroot juice (dietary nitrate)0–––00.0
Beta-glucan (oat and barley)0–––00.0
Betaine (trimethylglycine)0E––00.0
Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis BB-120–––00.0
Black ginger0–––00.0
Bladderwrack0–––00.0
BPC-1570–––00.0
Branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs)0–––00.0
Butcher's broom0–––00.0
Caffeine0E––00.0
California poppy0–––00.0
Carrageenan and agar0–––00.0
Chlorella0–––00.0
Citicoline (CDP-choline)0–––00.0
Cocoa flavanols0–––00.0
Devil's claw0–––00.0
Ephedra0–––00.0
European mistletoe0E––00.0
Fennel0–––00.0
GLA oils (borage and blackcurrant seed oil)0–––00.0
Glucomannan0–––00.0
Goji0–––00.0
Guarana0E––00.0
Guayusa0–––00.0
Hibiscus (roselle)0–––00.0
Java turmeric0–––00.0
Kudzu root0–––00.0
L-citrulline0–––00.0
Lacticaseibacillus paracasei strain Shirota (LcS)0–––00.0
Lactiplantibacillus plantarum 299v0–––00.0
Lactotripeptides (IPP and VPP)0–––00.0
Lemon balm0E––00.0
Limosilactobacillus reuteri DSM 179380–––00.0
Linoleic acid0–––00.0
Lycopene0–––00.0
MCT oil (medium-chain triglycerides)0–––00.0
MSM (methylsulfonylmethane)0–––00.0
Myo-inositol0–––00.0
Neem0–––00.0
Olive leaf extract0–––00.0
Pelargonium sidoides0–––00.0
Perilla0–––00.0
Phosphatidylserine0–––00.0
Prickly pear0–––00.0
Pumpkin seed0–––00.0
Purslane0–––00.0
Resistant starch0–––00.0
Rooibos0–––00.0
Rose hip0–––00.0
Sea moss0–––00.0
Spearmint0–––00.0
Stinging nettle0E––00.0
Streptococcus salivarius K120–––00.0
Sulforaphane0–––00.0
Tart cherry0–––00.0
Taurine0–––00.0
Thyme0–––00.0
Velvet bean (Mucuna)0–––00.0
Vitamin K2 (menaquinone-7)0–––00.0
Whey protein0–––00.0
Method, assumptions and limits: Quality-Risk Index
What it calculates
A weighted mean of five documented signals (adulteration reports, LiverTox category, IARC or NTP evaluation, IUCN or CITES status, NDI notifications), each scaled 0 to 1, multiplied by 100.
Assumptions
Signals are additive; absence of a record scores 0. LiverTox likelihood categories as defined by NIH (“Categorization of the likelihood of drug induced liver injury”, updated May 4, 2019); IARC group names as on the IARC list of classifications (last updated July 23, 2026).
What it does not establish
Whether a product is adulterated, contaminated or safe; the risk to any person; or whether FDA objected to any NDI notification.
Verification
As for the Evidence Strength Index: the published values, the on-page recomputation and an independent pandas calculation agree.
Process Published model reproduced

CQA and design-space explorer for an ethanol–water extraction

The model is the published ultrasound-assisted extraction of defatted black cumin seed (Gueffai et al. 2022), already rebuilt on the design space and optimization page. Its three factors are ethanol, sonication temperature and sonication time; its two responses are total phenolic content (TPC) and DPPH radical scavenging, a test-tube assay.

Critical quality attribute (CQA)
“A physical, chemical, biological or microbiological property or characteristic that should be within an appropriate limit, range, or distribution to ensure the desired product quality.”
Critical process parameter (CPP)
“A process parameter whose variability has an impact on a critical quality attribute and therefore should be monitored or controlled to ensure the process produces the desired quality.”
Design space
“The multidimensional combination and interaction of input variables (e.g., material attributes) and process parameters that have been demonstrated to provide assurance of quality.” The guideline adds: “Working within the design space is not considered as a change.”

ICH Q8(R2) Pharmaceutical Development, Part II glossary (Step 4 version dated August 2009). The U.S. dietary supplement CGMP rule, 21 CFR Part 111, does not use the term design space; the concepts are used here as engineering method.

Interactive calculator Change the inputs and the result updates. An educational simulation with stated inputs.

Second-order model in coded units (Table 2 coefficients)ŷ = β0 + Σβixi + Σβiixi2 + Σβijxixj, x1 = (ethanol − 60)/30
Predicted TPC at the point–
Predicted DPPH at the point–
Probability a new run meets both limits–
Share of the slice (inside the design sphere) at or above the required probability–

Response surface over ethanol and temperature at the chosen timePublished coefficients

Three-dimensional response surface of the selected response over ethanol and temperature at the chosen sonication time; amber marks where the probability of meeting both limits reaches the required level. The readouts and the probability map below give the same information as numbers.

Design space: probability that a new run meets both CQA limitsComputed from published data
Coefficients: Gueffai et al. 2022, Table 2 (coded units; the page uses the published values). Probability: posterior predictive bivariate Student t with 5 degrees of freedom from the 16 runs of Table 1, 4,000 shared random draws, as on the design space page; a Bayesian design space of the kind proposed by Peterson (2008). Outside the dashed circle the model extrapolates beyond the Box–Behnken design.

What the published model contains, and what it does not

Factors and attributes in the published model
Factor or attributeRoleIn the published model
Ethanol, % v/v (30–90)Process parameterYes, x1
Sonication temperature, °C (25–75)Process parameterYes, x2
Sonication time, min (15–45)Process parameterYes, x3
Solvent-to-solid ratioProcess parameterNo. Fixed at 5 g of powder in 200 mL (1:40); no coefficient exists, so none is shown.
Total phenolic content, mg GAE/gQuality attribute (marker-class content)Yes, response 1
DPPH radical scavenging, %Quality attribute (in vitro activity assay)Yes, response 2. A chemical assay; it says nothing about effects in people.
Extraction yield, residual ethanolQuality attributes often specifiedNo. Not measured in the study; adding them would require invented coefficients.
Method, assumptions and limits: design-space explorer
What it calculates
Mean TPC and DPPH from the published second-order models, and the posterior predictive probability that a new run at the chosen conditions meets both limits.
Equations
ŷ = z′β with z = (1, x1, x2, x3, x1x2, x1x3, x2x3, x12, x22, x32); new-run prediction y | x ~ tν(B′z, (1 + h)S/ν), ν = 5, h = z′(X′X)−1z, S the residual cross-product matrix of the least-squares refit.
Assumptions
The second-order model holds inside the design sphere (radius √2 in coded units); noninformative prior; residuals of the two responses correlated as observed (r = −0.80). Both models show significant lack of fit in the paper, so predictions carry more error than R² suggests.
Valid range
Inside the dashed circle. Readouts outside it carry a warning.
What it does not establish
A demonstrated design space in the ICH sense, which requires confirmation runs and scale-up evidence; any property of a commercial extract; any health effect.
Verification
An independent script recomputes predictions with NumPy and the probability exactly by quadrature over the chi-square mixing variable (Owen's T function), cross-checked against scipy.stats.multivariate_t; the automated test compares them with this page's Monte Carlo values.
Stability Published data reanalyzed

Shelf-life and stability calculator from accelerated rate constants

Enter degradation rate constants measured at several temperatures; the calculator fits the Arrhenius equation, extrapolates the rate to the storage temperature and gives the time to a chosen loss with its 95% confidence interval. The default data are published rate constants for two marker compounds in an Aquilaria crassna leaf extract (Wongwad et al. 2020).

Accelerated testing
“Studies designed to increase the rate of chemical degradation or physical change of a drug substance or drug product by using exaggerated storage conditions as part of the formal stability studies. … Results from accelerated testing studies are not always predictive of physical changes.” (ICH Q1A(R2), glossary)
Shelf life
“The time period during which a drug product is expected to remain within the approved shelf life specification, provided that it is stored under the conditions defined on the container label.” (ICH Q1A(R2), glossary)
Extrapolation
“An extrapolation of stability data assumes that the same change pattern will continue to apply beyond the period covered by long-term data. The correctness of the assumed change pattern is critical when extrapolation is considered.” and “a retest period or shelf life granted on the basis of extrapolation should always be verified by additional long-term stability data as soon as these data become available.” (ICH Q1E, section 2.3)

ICH Q1A(R2) Stability Testing of New Drug Substances and Products and ICH Q1E Evaluation of Stability Data, both Step 4 versions dated 6 February 2003. Q1E does not mention the Arrhenius equation. The dietary supplement CGMP rule (21 CFR Part 111) does not require an expiration date, but FDA says a firm “should have data to support any such date that you place on a product label” (FDA, Small Entity Compliance Guide for 21 CFR Part 111, citing 72 FR 34752 at 34855). A related single-point estimate with an assumed activation energy is on the quality by design page.

Interactive calculator Change the inputs and the result updates. An educational simulation with stated inputs.

Arrhenius fit and time to a loss Lln k = ln A − Ea/(RT)
first order: tL = −ln(1 − L)/k · zero order: tL = L/k
Temperature, °C and rate constant k

Leave a row empty to drop it; at least three temperatures are needed for an interval.

Activation energy Ea–
k at storage temperature–
Time to the allowed loss–
95% interval, shortest–
95% interval, longest–
R² of the Arrhenius fit–

Arrhenius plot: measured rate constants, fit and extrapolationPublished rate constants
Predicted content at the storage temperatureModel output
Rate constants: Wongwad E et al., Molecules 2020;25(21):4898, Tables 1 and 2 (dried extract, 50 mg per tube; solution, 15 mg/mL in pH 5.0 citrate buffer; 28 days). Fit and interval computed by EUTECNIQ. The band covers the statistical uncertainty of the fit only.
Worked example: recomputing the published shelf-life table

Refitting the published rate constants reproduces the paper's activation energies to within 0.4%. The paper states its method: t90% = −ln(0.9)/kp, with kp the rate at 25 °C read from the Arrhenius line. Applied at 25 °C (1/T = 1/298.15 K = 0.003354 K−1), that method gives the shorter times in the “refit” column, and the paper's own Ea and A give nearly the same shorter times for four of the five data sets. The calculator reports these values.

The paper's Table 3 values are reproduced, to within 4%, when 1/T is taken as 0.0034 K−1, that is, 0.003354 rounded to two figures, which corresponds to about 294 K (21 °C) instead of 298 K (last column). The paper's own Ea and A at 0.0034 K−1 also give its kp values for the four data sets. This is EUTECNIQ's reconstruction; the paper does not state it. For compound 1 in the dried extract the printed frequency factor, 23 × 1019 day−1, is about 18 times the refit value (1.26 × 1019) and does not reproduce the table's kp at either temperature. If this reconstruction is right, the published shelf lives correspond to about 21 °C, not 25 °C. The 95% intervals widen where the four points scatter about the line; for compound 1 in the dried extract the longest and shortest times differ by more than a factor of ten after a 15 °C extrapolation.

Paper's Table 3 compared with the refit (first order, t90 = time to 10% loss)
Data setEa, paperEa, refitt90, paper (stated as 25 °C)t90, refit at 25 °C95% interval, refit at 25 °Ct90, refit at 1/T = 0.0034 K−1
Compound 1, dried extract129.86129.99989 d495 d127–1,936 d1,016 d
Compound 2, dried extract110.57110.82248 d138 d116–166 d256 d
Compound 1, solution86.8387.17189 d119 d25–562 d193 d
Compound 2, solution51.4951.5113 d10 d4–27 d13 d
Mangiferin, solution65.2865.3975 d53 d18–159 d76 d

Paper values quoted from Wongwad et al. 2020, Table 3 (Ea in kJ/mol; t90% in days). Refit values computed with SciPy from Tables 1–2.

Method, assumptions and limits: shelf-life calculator
What it calculates
An ordinary least-squares line of ln k against 1/T, the rate constant at the storage temperature, and the time to the allowed loss for zero- or first-order kinetics.
Equations
ln k = ln A − (Ea/R)(1/T); R = 8.314462618 J/(mol·K); T in kelvin. 95% interval of ln k at Ts: ŷ0 ± t0.975, n−2 · s · √[1/n + (x0 − x̄)²/Sxx], x = 1/T. First order: C/C0 = e−kt; zero order: C/C0 = 1 − kt/100.
Assumptions
One degradation mechanism at every temperature; Arrhenius behavior between the test and storage temperatures; no effect of humidity, oxygen, light, phase change or package; the interval reflects scatter of the rate constants only.
What it does not establish
A shelf life or expiration date. Q1E describes, as an appropriate approach, estimating shelf life from long-term data as the earliest time at which the 95% confidence limit for the mean (one-sided, lower, for an attribute that decreases) intersects the acceptance criterion.
Verification
An independent script (scipy.stats.linregress and Student t quantiles) checks all five published data sets and a zero-order example.
Safety Agency values

Intake and margin-of-exposure calculator against agency values

Add up a daily intake from servings and other sources and compare it with a tolerable upper intake level (UL), an acceptable daily intake (ADI), an agency safe level or a no-observed-adverse-effect level (NOAEL). The 30 values come from the A–Z entries, each with its agency source. The toxicology and dose course explains how these values are derived.

Interactive calculator Change the inputs and the result updates. An educational simulation with stated inputs.

Intake, exposure and marginI = a · n + b · E = I/BW · % of reference = 100 · I / (RV or RVkg · BW) · MOE = NOAEL / E
Daily intake I, mg–
Exposure E, mg/kg bw per day–
Share of the reference value–
Margin of exposure (NOAEL ÷ E)–

Daily intake against the reference valueYour inputs
Worked example: glycyrrhizinic acid from licorice confectionerySCF 2003 data
EU Scientific Committee on Food, Opinion on glycyrrhizinic acid and its ammonium salt (10 April 2003): NOAEL 2 mg/kg bw/day from an 8-week study in healthy women, “on average equal to ca. 130 mg/person/day” (65 kg is the body weight that conversion implies); upper limit for regular ingestion 100 mg/day; regular Dutch consumers of licorice confectionery took on average about 19 mg/day, 42 mg/day at the 90th percentile and up to about 313 mg/day.
The 30 reference values and the sentence each comes from
Reference values used by the calculator
ValueTypeValue and basisAgencySource sentence (A–Z entry)
Glycyrrhizinic acid: NOAEL (human study)NOAEL2 mg per kg body weight per dayEU Scientific Committee on Food, 2003EU Scientific Committee on Food (2003): an upper limit for regular ingestion of 100 mg/day of glycyrrhizinic acid provides sufficient protection for the majority of the population (NOAEL 2 mg/kg bw/da …
Glycyrrhizinic acid: upper limit for regular ingestionUpper limit100 mg per dayEU Scientific Committee on Food, 2003EU Scientific Committee on Food (2003): an upper limit for regular ingestion of 100 mg/day of glycyrrhizinic acid provides sufficient protection for the majority of the population (NOAEL 2 mg/kg bw/da …
Boron: adult ULUL20 mg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSAdult UL: 20 mg/day (ages 19 and older, including pregnancy and lactation). No UL is established for infants; breast milk, formula and food should be their only sources.
Calcium: UL, ages 19–50UL2,500 mg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSAdult UL: 2,500 mg/day ages 19–50 (including pregnancy and lactation); 2,000 mg/day ages 51 and older. The ULs are based on Women's Health Initiative data linking 1,000 mg/day supplemental calcium to …
Choline: adult ULUL3,500 mg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSUL for adults 19 and older (including pregnancy and lactation): 3,500 mg/day, based on amounts associated with low blood pressure (hypotension) and fishy body odor.
Copper: adult ULUL10,000 mcg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSAdult UL: 10,000 mcg/day (including pregnancy and lactation). The ULs do not apply to individuals receiving supplemental copper under medical supervision.
Folic acid (synthetic folate): adult ULUL1,000 mcg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSUL, adults 19+ (including pregnancy and lactation): 1,000 mcg/day for the synthetic forms of folate (e.g., folic acid and 5-methyl-THF) in dietary supplements and fortified foods. No UL for folate fro …
Iodine: adult ULUL1,100 mcg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSAdult UL: 1,100 mcg/day (ages 19 and older, including pregnancy and lactation).
Iron: adult ULUL45 mg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSAdult UL: 45 mg/day (including pregnancy and lactation), based on gastrointestinal effects of supplemental iron salts.
Magnesium (supplemental only): adult ULUL350 mg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSAdult UL: 350 mg/day of supplemental magnesium (including pregnancy and lactation). The UL includes only magnesium from dietary supplements and medications, not food.
Manganese: adult ULUL11 mg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSAdult UL: 11 mg/day. The ULs do not apply to individuals taking supplemental manganese under medical supervision.
Molybdenum: adult ULUL2,000 mcg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSAdult UL: 2,000 mcg/day (including pregnancy and lactation), based on impaired reproduction and fetal development in rats and mice, given the absence of human studies.
Niacin (supplemental only): adult ULUL35 mg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSUL, adults 19+ (including pregnancy and lactation): 35 mg. The UL applies only to supplemental niacin, not to individuals receiving supplemental niacin under medical supervision.
Selenium: adult ULUL400 mcg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSAdult UL: 400 mcg/day. The UL does not apply to people taking selenium under a physician's care.
Vitamin A (preformed): adult ULUL3,000 mcg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSUL, adults 19+ (including pregnancy and lactation): 3,000 mcg/day. The UL applies only to preformed vitamin A (retinol and retinyl esters from animal sources), not to beta-carotene.
Vitamin B6: adult ULUL100 mg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSUL, adults 19+ (including pregnancy and lactation): 100 mg/day, applying to both food and supplement intakes; it does not apply to individuals receiving vitamin B6 for medical treatment, who should be …
Vitamin C: adult ULUL2,000 mg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSUL, adults 19+ (including pregnancy and lactation): 2,000 mg/day, applying to both food and supplement intakes; it does not apply to individuals receiving vitamin C for medical treatment.
Vitamin D: adult ULUL100 mcg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSUL, adults 19+ (including pregnancy and lactation): 100 mcg (4,000 IU)/day. ODS notes that intakes below the UL could also cause harm over time.
Vitamin E (supplemental alpha-tocopherol): adult ULUL1,000 mg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSUL, adults 19+ (including pregnancy and lactation): 1,000 mg/day, applying to all forms of supplemental alpha-tocopherol; equivalent to 1,500 IU/day of the natural form or 1,100 IU/day of the syntheti …
Zinc: adult ULUL40 mg per dayFood and Nutrition Board, via NIH ODSAdult UL: 40 mg/day (including pregnancy and lactation), from food and supplements combined. The ULs do not apply to individuals receiving zinc for medical treatment.
Astaxanthin: ADIADI0.2 mg per kg body weight per dayEFSA, 2019–2020EFSA acceptable daily intake (ADI): 0.2 mg astaxanthin per kg body weight (set by the FEEDAP Panel in 2019).
Nitrate: ADI (all dietary sources)ADI3.7 mg per kg body weight per dayEFSA, 2017EU: the acceptable daily intake for nitrate is 3.7 mg per kg body weight per day; EFSA noted it would be exceeded in all age groups at mean and high intakes when all dietary sources are counted.
Carrageenan (E 407, E 407a): temporary group ADIADI75 mg per kg body weight per dayEFSA, 2018EFSA (2018): group acceptable daily intake of 75 mg/kg body weight per day for carrageenan (E 407) and processed Eucheuma seaweed (E 407a), considered temporary pending better data.
Lutein from Tagetes erecta (E 161b): ADIADI1 mg per kg body weight per dayEFSA, 2010EFSA (2010) set an acceptable daily intake (ADI) of 1 mg/kg body weight per day for lutein from Tagetes erecta used as a food additive (E 161b).
Steviol glycosides (as steviol): ADIADI4 mg per kg body weight per dayJECFA, as stated by FDAAcceptable daily intake (ADI) for steviol glycosides: 4 mg/kg body weight per day, expressed as steviol equivalents (set by JECFA, as stated by FDA).
Betaine: safe additional intake (novel food)Safe level400 mg per dayEFSA, 2017EU (EFSA, 2017): for betaine as a novel food, 400 mg/day (6 mg/kg body weight per day for adults) in addition to background dietary exposure is considered safe, derived from 4 g/day as a reference poi …
Nicotinamide riboside chloride: safe level, adultsSafe level300 mg per dayEFSA, 2019EU: EFSA concluded nicotinamide riboside chloride is safe as a novel food at up to 300 mg/day for healthy adults (excluding pregnancy and lactation) and up to 230 mg/day for pregnant and lactating wom …
Ecklonia cava phlorotannins: safe level, adultsSafe level263 mg per dayEFSA, 2017EFSA (2017) concluded the EU novel-food extract is safe in food supplements at up to 263 mg/day for adults, 230 mg/day for adolescents over 14 and 163 mg/day for adolescents aged 12-14.
Thujone from sage preparations: daily exposure limitUpper limit6 mg per dayEMA HMPC monograph, 2016EU (EMA HMPC monograph, 2016): the amount of thujone has to be specified in the product, and daily thujone exposure has to be below 6.0 mg.
Caffeine: amount not generally associated with negative effects, most adultsGuidance400 mg per dayFDAFDA: for most adults, 400 mg a day is an amount not generally associated with negative effects.

ULs are for healthy adults; several apply only to supplemental intake (magnesium, niacin, folic acid, vitamin E) and some do not apply under medical supervision, as each A–Z entry states. A UL or ADI is not an intake target.

Method, assumptions and limits: intake and margin of exposure
What it calculates
Total daily intake, intake per kilogram of body weight, its share of the selected reference value and, for a NOAEL, the margin of exposure.
Variables and units
a, b in the chosen unit (converted to mg); n servings per day; BW in kg. Per-kilogram values (ADI, NOAEL) are compared with E; per-day values (UL, safe level) with I.
Assumptions
The label amount is the amount taken; all sources add; a chronic daily value is compared with a daily intake.
Interpretation
An MOE of 1 means the exposure equals the NOAEL. What margin is adequate depends on the data behind the NOAEL: assessors apply uncertainty factors, conventionally 10 for differences between species and 10 between people when the NOAEL comes from animals. EFSA regards an MOE of 10,000 or more as of low concern only for substances that are both genotoxic and carcinogenic, when based on an animal BMDL10; see the risk assessment page.
What it does not establish
Whether an intake is right or safe for a person. It is not dosing advice; ask a doctor or pharmacist about your own intake.
Verification
A script extracts each value from the A–Z data with a pattern and fails if it changes; a second script recomputes eight cases.
Engineering First-principles model

Spray-drying mass and energy balance from air flow and temperatures

Given the air flow and the inlet and outlet temperatures of a running dryer, the balance gives how much water it can evaporate, the feed rate that matches, the exhaust humidity and the powder collected at a given yield. The process engineering page has the inverse calculator, which sizes the air from a feed rate.

Interactive calculator Change the inputs and the result updates. An educational simulation with stated inputs.

Steady-state balance on the drying chamber (reference: dry air and liquid water at 0 °C)G·h(Tin, W0) + F·hf = G·h(Tout, W1) + P·hp + f·Qh
h(t, W) = 1.006 t + W(2501 + 1.86 t) kJ/kg dry air; G·W1 = G·W0 + E
Dry air G, kg/h–
Feed the air can dry F, kg/h–
Water evaporated E (TWEC), kg/h–
Water evaporated for collected powder (EWEC), kg/h–
Powder collected, kg/h–
Heater duty Qh, kW–
Heat per kg water evaporated, MJ–
Thermal efficiency η, %–
Exhaust humidity W1, g/kg–
Exhaust relative humidity, %–

Where the heater duty goesModel output
Feed the dryer can take as the inlet temperature changesModel output
Worked example: a semi-industrial dryer drying chokeberry juicePublished data

Gawałek (2022) dried chokeberry (aronia) juice concentrate with maltodextrin (35% dry matter) in a Niro FU 11 DA dryer with a rotary atomizer at 12,000 rpm and 460 m³/h of air, with the outlet held at 89 ± 1 °C by adjusting the feed within 10–15 L/h; inlet temperatures ran from 150 to 185 °C, and 165 °C was the inlet used for the series at different feed concentrations. Powder moisture was 2.15–3.22% (wet basis); powder yield peaked at 91.6–94.4% between 160 and 170 °C; measured specific energy consumption over 150–185 °C was 8,364–10,524 kJ per kg of water, including heater and fan electricity, with the minimum at 170 °C. The table compares the balance at 165 °C with that whole range.

The balance at the published conditions (air volume taken at 20 °C, 8 g/kg; moisture 2.7%, the middle of the reported range; yield 92%)
QuantityModelPublished
Feed the air can dry with no wall loss–10–15 L/h (density not reported)
Wall loss that matches the lowest measured energy use (8,364 kJ/kg)–8,364–10,524 kJ/kg water
Wall loss that matches the highest measured energy use (10,524 kJ/kg)–

Without losses the air could dry more feed than the published 10–15 L/h; a semi-industrial chamber loses heat through its walls, and the measured energy also includes the fan, so the implied loss is an upper estimate. Gawałek's Equation 3 for EWEC omits the factor (1 − WCp) on the feed-water term; the page uses the exact balance, which differs from it by about the powder moisture.

Gawałek J. Spray drying of chokeberry juice—antioxidant phytochemicals retention in the obtained powders versus energy consumption of the process. Foods 2022;11(18):2898 (CC BY 4.0), sections 2.2–2.6 and 3.1–3.4.

Psychrometric relations: ASHRAE Handbook—Fundamentals (2017), ch. 1, eqns 20, 26 and 30, with the coefficients as implemented in PsychroLib (Meyer and Thevenard 2019); saturation pressure of water: IAPWS-IF97 region 4 (IAPWS R7-97, 2012). Thermal efficiency η = (Tin − Tout)/(Tin − T0), a temperature ratio defined here. Yield, TWEC and EWEC as defined by Gawałek 2022.
Method, assumptions and limits: spray-drying balance
What it calculates
Dry-air mass flow from the volume flow, heater duty, the feed rate that closes the energy balance at the chosen outlet temperature, water evaporated, exhaust humidity and relative humidity, powder made and collected, heat per kilogram of water and the thermal efficiency η.
Equations
v = 0.287042 (T + 273.15)(1 + 1.607858 W)/101.325 m³/kg dry air; G = V̇/v; Qh = G[h(Tin, W0) − h(T0, W0)]; e = (1 − xs) − xsxp/(1 − xp), p = xs/(1 − xp); F = [G(h(Tin, W0) − h(Tout, W0)) − fQh] / [e(2501 + 1.86 Tout) + p·cPTout − hf]; E = eF; W1 = W0 + E/G; pv = p W1/(0.621945 + W1); RH = pv/pws(Tout); EWEC = PY·E.
Variables and units
Temperatures in °C; W in kg water per kg dry air; cw = 4.184 and dry-solids cs = 1.5 kJ/(kg·K) (assumed, as on the process engineering page); hf = (1 − xs)cwTf + xscsTf; cP = (1 − xp)cs + xpcw; atmospheric pressure 101.325 kPa.
Assumptions
Steady state; powder leaves at the outlet air temperature; all solids leave as powder at the stated moisture (uncollected powder is dried too); heat loss is a fixed fraction of heater duty; no heat of solution or crystallization.
What it does not establish
Whether the powder will stick, degrade or reach the stated moisture at these conditions; those depend on the glass transition and drying kinetics (see drying and particle engineering).
Verification
An independent script solves the same balance with CoolProp humid-air properties and IAPWS-95 water enthalpy (brentq root finding); the page's ideal-gas relations agree within 2% for the five test cases.

Pro is a plan, and the tools are free while in preview

Tell EUTECNIQ which tools or data you would use. Joining the waiting list is not a purchase or commitment.

Health information notice

These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Nothing on this site is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. The information is for general education only. It is not medical advice and does not replace advice, diagnosis or treatment from a qualified health professional, or any medication a clinician has prescribed.

Do not start, stop or change any medicine, supplement or herbal product because of something you read here. Talk to your doctor or pharmacist first, especially if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, have a medical condition, take any medicines, are preparing for surgery, or are caring for a child. Research findings, traditional uses and safety data are reported as their sources state them; they are not recommendations or claims about any product. If you think you may have a medical emergency, call your doctor or 911 at once.

EUTECNIQ Sciences sells no supplements or health products today and receives nothing from any product or ingredient mentioned on this site; any commercial interest it later has in an ingredient will be stated on that ingredient’s page.

Ready to check what you take?

Free tools built on published reference values, each with its sources and its limits. Your lists stay in your browser.