EUTECNIQAtlas

Every page of EUTECNIQ on one mapArrow keys move through results · Enter opens · Esc closes

Reference library eCFR, EU and Codex texts Peer-reviewed data FDA reference values

Kill steps and sanitation

A kill step is specified as a number of decimal reductions of a named organism at a stated time and temperature, dose or pressure. A surface counts as clean only when the cleaning has been verified.

5-logMinimum reduction of the most resistant pathogen likely in a juice, delivered by every juice HACCP plan (21 CFR 120.24)
2.8 minAt 121.1 °C, the time for 12 decimal reductions of proteolytic C. botulinum spores at the top published D-value (FAO)
30 vs 10 kGyMaximum irradiation dose for herbs and spices in the United States (21 CFR 179.26) and in the EU (Directive 1999/3/EC)
1.5 m/sPipeline velocity that keeps clean-in-place flow turbulent (Oklahoma State University Extension)

eCFR, titles 21 and 40, up to date as of October 26, 2026; FAO Fisheries Circular 784 (1985), Table 1; Directive 1999/3/EC, Annex; Bowser TJ, FAPC-251 (2023).

Kinetics

Decimal reduction and F-value

Process design uses a first-order model: at constant temperature, each D minutes kills 90% of the surviving population, so the logarithm of survivors falls on a straight line. An FDA-commissioned review notes "various types of deviations from this historical model" with no accepted replacement, so published D-values are design inputs, not guarantees.

Low-acid canning targets 12 decimal reductions (12D) of Clostridium botulinum spores. FDA's worked example: 104 spores per can and a 12D process leave a theoretical 10−8 survivors per can.

First-order inactivation and thermal lethalitylog10(N/N0) = −t/D   D(T) = Dref × 10(Tref − T)/z   F = ∫ 10(T(t) − Tref)/z dt
F0: Tref = 121.1 °C (250 °F), z = 10 °C (18 °F)   12D at D121.1 = 0.23 min: 12 × 0.23 = 2.76 min
Twelve decimal reductions take 2.76 min at 121.1 °C and 11.2 min at 115 °CComputed FAO D and z
Survivor curves for proteolytic Clostridium botulinum spores computed from D at 121.1 °C of 0.23 min and z of 10 °C: starting from 10,000 spores in a container, 12 decimal reductions take 2.8 min at 121.1 °C and 11.2 min at 115 °C and leave a calculated 10 to the minus 8 survivors per container−10−8−6−4−2024log₁₀ surviving spores per container024681012Time at constant temperature (min)121.1 °C115 °C1 spore per container12D = 2.76 min12D = 11.2 min121.1 °C115 °CReading the curveD, decimal reduction timeminutes at one temperature for a 90% (1-log) killSlope of each line−1/D; here D₁₂₁.₁ = 0.23 minD at 115 °C0.23 × 10(121.1−115)/10​ = 0.94 min12D processlog₁₀ N = 4 − 12 = −8: one container in 10⁸ wouldhold a survivorF₀equivalent minutes at 121.1 °C with z = 10 °C; this12D needs F₀ = 12 × 0.23 = 2.76 minFirst-order model. The FDA example of 10⁴ spores per can is used as the starting load; the 10⁻⁸ end point is a probability, not a count.
D121.1 0.1–0.23 min and z 10 °C for C. botulinum types A and B: FAO Fisheries Circular 784, Fish canning (1985), Table 1; the upper value is plotted. Starting load and 12D end point: FDA, Inspection Technical Guide 7, Sterilizing symbols D, z, F. First-order model; the end point is a probability.
Published D- and z-values for pathogens and spore formers
OrganismMediumT (°C)D (min)z (°C)Source
C. botulinum A and B sporesCanning reference121.10.1–0.2310FAO 1985
C. botulinum 62A sporesPhosphate buffer, pH 7.01100.88–1.97.6–10ICMSF 1996, via FDA–IFT 2000
C. botulinum proteolytic B sporesVegetable products1100.49–12.427.4–10.8ICMSF 1996, via FDA–IFT 2000
C. botulinum non-proteolytic BFDA reference, "generally conservative"901.67*7 (<90 °C), 10 (>90 °C)FDA, Appendix 4, Table A-4
C. botulinum type E sporesSeafood746.8–139.78ICMSF 1996, via FDA–IFT 2000
Bacillus cereus sporesVarious media951.5–36.26.7–10.1ICMSF 1996, via FDA–IFT 2000
Listeria monocytogenesFDA reference, all foods700.33*7.5FDA, Appendix 4, Table A-3
L. monocytogenesMilk63.30.22–0.585.5ICMSF 1996, via FDA–IFT 2000
Salmonella SenftenbergMilk65.60.564.4ICMSF 1996, via FDA–IFT 2000
Staphylococcus aureusMilk600.99.5ICMSF 1996, via FDA–IFT 2000

*Derived: FDA gives 6D times (10 min at 90 °C; 2.0 min at 70 °C), divided here by 6. FDA, Fish and Fishery Products Hazards and Controls Guidance, Appendix 4. ICMSF data as tabulated in IFT, Kinetics of Microbial Inactivation for Alternative Food Processing Technologies, report for FDA (2000), Tables 1, 2, 9, 11 and 12. D depends on strain, medium, pH and water activity; values from one medium do not transfer to another.

z-value

Equivalent time and temperature

Because D falls tenfold for every z degrees, one lethality target can be met by many time–temperature pairs. U.S. rules fix the target in three ways: as a log reduction (juice), as legal time–temperature pairs (milk) or as commercial sterility under a scheduled process (low-acid canned foods).

Each target is a straight line on a log-time axis; a steeper line means a smaller zFDA reference values Breidt et al. 2014 21 CFR 1240.61
Equivalent time and temperature for five published lethality targets on a log time axis: Listeria monocytogenes 6D (z 7.5 °C), non-proteolytic Clostridium botulinum type B 6D, vegetative pathogens 5-log in acidified foods pH 4.1 to 4.6, proteolytic C. botulinum 12D computed with z 10 °C, and the legal milk pasteurization points from 63 °C for 30 min to 100 °C for 0.01 s0.00010.0010.010.11101001000Time at temperature (min, log scale)5565758595105115125Temperature (°C)Listeria monocytogenes, 6DC. botulinum non-proteolytic B, 6DVegetative pathogens, 5-log, pH 4.1–4.6C. botulinum proteolytic, 12DMilk pasteurization, 21 CFR 1240.61: 63 °C for 1800 sMilk pasteurization, 21 CFR 1240.61: 72 °C for 15 sMilk pasteurization, 21 CFR 1240.61: 89 °C for 1 sMilk pasteurization, 21 CFR 1240.61: 90 °C for 0.5 sMilk pasteurization, 21 CFR 1240.61: 94 °C for 0.1 sMilk pasteurization, 21 CFR 1240.61: 96 °C for 0.05 sMilk pasteurization, 21 CFR 1240.61: 100 °C for 0.01 sL. monocytogenes 6DNon-proteolytic B 6DAcidified foods 5-logProteolytic 12DMilk, legal minimums12D: 2.76 min at 121.1 °Cz: the slope of each lineL. monocytogenesz 7.5 °C; 6D = 2.0 min at 70 °CNon-proteolytic Bz 7.0 °C below 90 °C, 10 °C above; 6D = 10min at 90 °CAcidified foodsz 16.7 °F (9.3 °C); 5-log = 5.6 min at 160 °F(71.1 °C)Proteolytic 12Dz 10 °C; D₁₂₁.₁ 0.23 min (computed line)Milk (dots)legal time–temperature pairs, not a z lineA rise of z degrees cuts the time tenfold.Listeria and non-proteolytic lines: FDA reference values with their z; acidified-food line joins published table values; proteolytic line computed. Each targetapplies to its own food and organism; the lines are not interchangeable.
FDA, Fish and Fishery Products Hazards and Controls Guidance, Appendix 4, Tables A-3 and A-4. Breidt F, Kay K, Osborne J, Ingham B, Arritt F. Food Prot Trends. 2014;34(3):132–138, Table 4. 21 CFR 1240.61(b). Proteolytic line computed from FAO Circular 784 (D121.1 0.23 min, z 10 °C).
U.S. regulatory definitions of kill steps
RuleWhat it requiresCitation
Juice HACCPAt least a 5-log reduction of the pertinent microorganism, the most resistant of public health significance likely to occur in the juice, for the shelf life. Applied to the juice itself, except that citrus processors may treat fruit surfaces after culling and cleaning. Exempt: processors under Part 113 or 114, or using one thermal step that makes the juice shelf-stable.21 CFR 120.24
Milk pasteurizationEvery particle held at 63 °C for 30 min, 72 °C for 15 s, 89 °C for 1 s, 90 °C for 0.5 s, 94 °C for 0.1 s, 96 °C for 0.05 s or 100 °C for 0.01 s; the first two rise by 3 °C at 10% fat or more or with added sweeteners.21 CFR 1240.61(b)
Ultra-pasteurized dairyAt or above 138 °C (280 °F) for at least 2 s, for an extended shelf life under refrigeration.21 CFR 131.3(c)
Low-acid canned foodFinished equilibrium pH above 4.6 and water activity above 0.85. A scheduled process from a competent processing authority must achieve commercial sterility: no microorganisms that can grow in the food unrefrigerated, and no viable spores of public health significance.21 CFR 113.3(e), (n), (r)
Acidified foodA low-acid food with added acid, water activity above 0.85 and finished equilibrium pH of 4.6 or below. Refrigerated foods, jams, jellies and carbonated beverages are excluded.21 CFR 114.3(b)

eCFR, 21 CFR 113.3, 114.3, 120.24, 131.3 and 1240.61, up to date as of October 26, 2026. The definitions are given as reference points; which part applies to a given product is a question for counsel.

Filling routes

Hot, cold, aseptic and ambient fill

The filling route decides where the kill happens. Hot fill uses the product's own heat to treat the container. Cold fill moves the kill upstream and relies on pH and preservatives. Aseptic filling sterilizes product and containers separately and joins them in a sterile zone. Dry products filled at ambient temperature have no kill step in the line.

Comparison of hot fill, cold fill, aseptic and ambient filling
RouteConditions stated by the sourceWhat it requires
Hot fill and holdProduct heated to about 82–93 °C (180–200 °F) and held 2–5 min in the inverted container [1]. For acidified foods at pH 4.1–4.6, a 5-log reduction of E. coli O157:H7, Salmonella and L. monocytogenes takes 5.6 min at 71.1 °C and 0.4 min at 82.2 °C [2].Equilibrium pH below 4.6; a container validated for the fill temperature [1]; a process set by a process authority.
Cold fill with preservativesNo heat in the container. At pH 3.3 or below with acetic acid, a 5-log reduction of E. coli O157:H7 took 5.7 days at 10 °C and 34.3 h at 25 °C [3]. Sodium benzoate is GRAS, with current usage up to 0.1% [4]; potassium sorbate is GRAS at good manufacturing practice [5].A juice still needs a validated 5-log reduction applied to the juice [6]; hygienic filling; pH and preservative levels held within specification.
AsepticProduct sterilized in a holding tube sloped upward at least 2.1 cm per meter, with the recorder at the tube outlet; in a product regenerator, sterile product is kept at higher pressure than unsterile product [7]. Container sterilant example: hydrogen peroxide solution of at most 35%, leaving no more than 0.5 ppm in water packaged under production conditions [8].Commercial sterility of the product and of the equipment and containers [9]; a scheduled process.
Ambient (dry)No kill step in the line. Contact surfaces for low-moisture products must be dry and sanitary in use, and dried after wet cleaning [10]. Release against limits such as USP ⟨2023⟩: dried or powdered botanicals, total aerobic count 105 cfu/g and yeasts and molds 103 cfu/g, Salmonella and E. coli absent in 10 g [11].Water activity low enough to stop growth (see below); any reduction must happen upstream, on the raw material.

[1] Casulli K. UGA Extension Circular 1328-02 (June 2025). [2] Breidt F, et al. Food Prot Trends. 2014;34(3):132–138, Table 4. [3] Breidt F, Hayes J, McFeeters RF. J Food Prot. 2007;70(11):2638–2641. [4] 21 CFR 184.1733(d). [5] 21 CFR 182.3640. [6] 21 CFR 120.24(b). [7] 21 CFR 113.40(g)(1). [8] 21 CFR 178.1005(a), (d). [9] 21 CFR 113.3(e). [10] 21 CFR 111.27(d)(2). [11] USP ⟨2023⟩, Table 2 (USP 35–NF 30).

Hot fill treats the container with the product's heat; cold fill and ambient fill need the kill earlier; aseptic sterilizes each part separatelySchematic
Four filling routes compared step by step: hot fill and hold, cold fill with a separate kill step and preservatives, aseptic processing with sterile product, containers and filling zone, and ambient dry filling that relies on low water activityHot fill and holdHeat productabout 82–93 °CFill hotclean containersCaphot closureInvert and hold2–5 min; heats cap andheadspaceCoolseal pulls a vacuumAcid or acidified products, pH below 4.6. Container must tolerate the fill temperature.Cold fillKill step before fillingjuice: validated 5-log(120.24)Preservatives, pHe.g., benzoate, sorbateChillFill coldhygienic fillerCap and storeas the product'svalidation requiresNo heat in the container. Safety rests on the earlier kill step, pH, preservatives and filler hygiene.AsepticSterilize productholding tube, scheduledprocessCoolregenerator: sterile sideat higher pressureAseptic surge tankSterilize containerse.g., H₂O₂ ≤ 35%Fill and seal in a sterilezoneProduct, containers and the zone between them are each made commercially sterile (21 CFR 113.3(e)(2), 113.40(g)).Ambient (dry)Blend dry ingredientswater activity set byformulationFill at roomtemperaturecapsule, tablet, powderSeal against moistureHold drycontact surfaces keptdry, 111.27(d)(2)Release on teste.g., USP <2023> limitsNo kill step in the line. Any reduction must happen upstream (raw-material treatment); low water activity stops growth, not survival.Four filling routes compared step by step: hot fill and hold, cold fill, aseptic and ambient dry fillingHot fill and holdHeat productabout 82–93 °CFill hotclean containersCaphot closureInvert and hold2–5 min; heats cap and headspaceCoolseal pulls a vacuumAcid or acidified products, pH below 4.6. Container musttolerate the fill temperature.Cold fillKill step before fillingjuice: validated 5-log (120.24)Preservatives, pHe.g., benzoate, sorbateChillFill coldhygienic fillerCap and storeas the product's validation requiresNo heat in the container. Safety rests on the earlier kill step,pH, preservatives and filler hygiene.AsepticSterilize productholding tube, scheduled processCoolregenerator: sterile side at higher pressureAseptic surge tankSterilize containerse.g., H₂O₂ ≤ 35%Fill and seal in a sterile zoneProduct, containers and the zone between them are each madecommercially sterile (21 CFR 113.3(e)(2), 113.40(g)).Ambient (dry)Blend dry ingredientswater activity set by formulationFill at room temperaturecapsule, tablet, powderSeal against moistureHold drycontact surfaces kept dry, 111.27(d)(2)Release on teste.g., USP <2023> limitsNo kill step in the line. Any reduction must happen upstream(raw-material treatment); low water activity stops growth, notsurvival.
Steps summarize the sources in the table above. Temperatures shown only where a cited source states them.
Non-thermal

Pressure, electric fields and UV-C

High pressure, pulsed electric fields and UV-C inactivate vegetative cells with little heating. None is a sterilization step on its own: bacterial spores resist high pressure and electric fields, and UV-C acts only where the light reaches.

High-pressure processing is a pasteurization; a 2022 review calls it "a cold pasteurization technology". C. botulinum 17B and Cap 9B spore suspensions tolerated 30 min at 827 MPa and 75 °C, beyond the 600 MPa at which most commercial machines operate.

High pressure processing, pulsed electric field and UV-C: operating range, what each inactivates and what it does not
TechnologyOperating rangeInactivatesDoes not reliably inactivateRule or note
High pressure processing (HPP)300–600 MPa, isostatic, in the final package; most commercial machines run at up to 600 MPa and below 45 °C after compression; a typical cycle holds 3 min at 600 MPa [1]Vegetative cells, including pathogens, at 600 MPa and room temperature [1]Most bacterial spores and enzymes [1]; C. botulinum spores survived 827 MPa at 75 °C for 30 min [2]Low-acid HPP products need cold chain (1–8 °C) and a limited shelf life [1]. Juice must still meet 5-log [3].
Pulsed electric field (PEF)20–80 kV/cm pulses, near ambient temperature, under 1 s of treatment [2]Vegetative cells; kinetic data scarce [2]Bacillus spores resisted fields up to 30 kV/cm; heat shock and lysozyme with PEF gave 2–4 log; one study reported 3.4 and 5 log at 50 kV/cm [2]Survivor data "too limited" for definite conclusions on kinetic parameters [2]
UV-C200–280 nm; at least 400 J/m² in every part of the product [2]Microorganisms in the light path, through DNA damage [2]Shaded regions; critical factors include product transmissivity and reactor geometry [2]21 CFR 179.39: low-pressure mercury lamps, 90% of emission at 253.7 nm; juice in turbulent flow, Reynolds number at least 2,200 [4]

[1] Houška M, Silva FVM, Evelyn, Buckow R, Terefe NS, Tonello C. Foods. 2022;11(2):223. [2] IFT, report for FDA, Kinetics of Microbial Inactivation for Alternative Food Processing Technologies (2000), HPP, PEF and UV chapters and overview. [3] 21 CFR 120.24. [4] 21 CFR 179.39(a), (b).

Ionizing radiation

Gamma, electron beam and X-ray

Gamma rays, electron beams and X-rays deposit energy measured in kilograys (kGy). U.S. rules allow up to 30 kGy for dried culinary herbs, seeds, spices and vegetable seasonings. The EU's only Union-wide authorization covers the same category at 10 kGy, and the Codex standard caps doses at 10 kGy unless a legitimate technological purpose requires more.

Electrons penetrate about 5 cm of food and X-rays 60–400 cm, which decides package size. At the permitted energies the food does not become radioactive: an FAO/IAEA/WHO consultation concluded that X-rays up to 7.5 MeV can be used "without concern about induced radioactivity in food".

Herbs and spices carry the highest routine U.S. dose limit, three times the EU and Codex figure21 CFR 179.26 EU and Codex
Irradiation dose scale in kilogray on a log axis: U.S. limits in 21 CFR 179.26 run from 0.3 to 1 kGy for Trichinella in pork to 30 kGy for culinary herbs, spices and seasonings, with a 44 kGy minimum for NASA space-flight meats; the EU authorizes only dried aromatic herbs, spices and vegetable seasonings, at 10 kGy, and the Codex standard sets a 10 kGy maximum except for a legitimate technological purpose0.10.3131030100Absorbed dose (kGy, log scale)Trichinella in porkTrichinella in pork: 0.3–1 kGy0.3–1Sprout and ripening inhibitionSprout and ripening inhibition: not more than 1 kGy≤ 1Arthropod disinfestationArthropod disinfestation: not more than 1 kGy≤ 1Shell eggs, SalmonellaShell eggs, Salmonella: not more than 3 kGy≤ 3Iceberg lettuce, spinachIceberg lettuce, spinach: not more than 4 kGy≤ 4Meat, refrigeratedMeat, refrigerated: not more than 4.5 kGy≤ 4.5Molluscan shellfishMolluscan shellfish: not more than 5.5 kGy≤ 5.5CrustaceansCrustaceans: not more than 6 kGy≤ 6Poultry and meat, frozenPoultry and meat, frozen: not more than 7 kGy≤ 7Seeds for sproutingSeeds for sprouting: not more than 8 kGy≤ 8Dry enzyme preparationsDry enzyme preparations: not more than 10 kGy≤ 10Herbs, spices, seasonings: U.S.Herbs, spices, seasonings: U.S.: not more than 30 kGy≤ 30Herbs, spices, seasonings: EUHerbs, spices, seasonings: EU: not more than 10 kGy≤ 10Codex general maximumCodex general maximum: not more than 10 kGy≤ 10NASA space-flight meats (minimum)NASA space-flight meats (minimum): at least 44 kGy≥ 44U.S., 21 CFR 179.26 (other uses)U.S. herbs and spicesEU list, Directive 1999/3/ECCodex CXS 106-1983, Rev.1-2003Bars run from the stated minimum (or from the axis edge where only a maximum is set) to the maximum. Codex allows more than 10 kGy only when necessary for a legitimatetechnological purpose.Irradiation dose limits in kilogray on a log axis: U.S. 21 CFR 179.26 uses from 0.3 to 30 kGy and a 44 kGy minimum for NASA meats; EU herbs and spices 10 kGy; Codex general maximum 10 kGyAbsorbed dose (kGy, log scale)0.1110100Trichinella in pork0.3–1Sprout and ripening inhibition≤ 1Arthropod disinfestation≤ 1Shell eggs, Salmonella≤ 3Iceberg lettuce, spinach≤ 4Meat, refrigerated≤ 4.5Molluscan shellfish≤ 5.5Crustaceans≤ 6Poultry and meat, frozen≤ 7Seeds for sprouting≤ 8Dry enzyme preparations≤ 10Herbs, spices, seasonings: U.S.≤ 30Herbs, spices, seasonings: EU≤ 10Codex general maximum≤ 10NASA space-flight meats (minimum)≥ 44U.S. 179.26, other usesU.S. herbs, spicesEU 1999/3/ECCodex CXS 106
21 CFR 179.26(b), uses 1–14; Directive 1999/3/EC, Annex; Codex General Standard for Irradiated Foods, CODEX STAN 106-1983, Rev.1-2003, § 2.2.
Irradiation rules for herbs and spices in the United States, the EU and Codex
RulePermitted sourcesHerbs and spicesLabeling and other conditions
United States, 21 CFR 179.26Gamma from cobalt-60 or cesium-137; electrons up to 10 MeV; X-rays up to 5 MeV, or 7.5 MeV with a tantalum or gold targetUp to 30 kGy for dry aromatic vegetable substances used in small amounts for flavor; turmeric and paprika also as color additivesRadura logo with "Treated with radiation" or "Treated by irradiation" on retail packages; not required for foods that merely contain an irradiated ingredient; "do not irradiate again" on shipments for further processing
EU, Directives 1999/2/EC and 1999/3/ECGamma from 60Co or 137Cs; X-rays up to 5 MeV; electrons up to 10 MeVDried aromatic herbs, spices and vegetable seasonings: 10 kGy maximum overall average absorbed dose"Irradiated" or "treated with ionising radiation" on the label, also beside an irradiated ingredient; Dmax/Dmin should not exceed 3; not a substitute for hygiene or good manufacturing practice; Member States may keep earlier national authorizations
Codex, CXS 106-1983, Rev.1-2003Gamma from 60Co or 137Cs; X-rays up to 5 MeV; electrons up to 10 MeVGeneral maximum 10 kGy, "except when necessary to achieve a legitimate technological purpose"No re-irradiation, except low-moisture foods treated against insect reinfestation; prepackaged foods labeled

eCFR, 21 CFR 179.26, up to date as of October 26, 2026. Directive 1999/2/EC, Article 6 and Annexes I–III, and Directive 1999/3/EC, Annex (OJ L 66, 13.3.1999). CODEX STAN 106-1983, Rev.1-2003, §§ 2.1, 2.2, 5. Penetration: IFT report for FDA (2000). Induced radioactivity: ICGFI consultants' meeting, The development of X-ray machines for food irradiation, Vienna, October 1995 (FAO/IAEA/WHO).

Spices and dried botanicals

Ethylene oxide and steam

U.S. tolerances still cover ethylene oxide used as a postharvest fumigant on dried herbs and spices: 7 ppm for the gas and 940 ppm for its reaction product 2-chloroethanol. A 2022 review states that it is banned in the United States; the current eCFR says otherwise. The EU prohibits its use on food and limits the sum of both, expressed as ethylene oxide, to the limit of quantification.

In September 2020 Belgium reported high levels in sesame seeds from India; Member States withdrew and recalled the seeds and products made from them. A spice fumigated lawfully for the U.S. market can therefore be unsaleable in the EU.

Ethylene oxide, steam and irradiation for decontaminating dried herbs and spices: United States and EU status and documented trade-offs
TreatmentUnited StatesEuropean UnionDocumented trade-offs
Ethylene oxide fumigationTolerances 7 ppm ethylene oxide and 940 ppm 2-chloroethanol in dried herbs and spices (group 19, except basil), licorice root, dried mint tops, sesame seed and dried vegetables [1]Use in food production prohibited; residue defined as the sum of ethylene oxide and 2-chloro-ethanol, expressed as ethylene oxide [2, 3]; sesame seed limit 0.05 mg/kg [4]BfR: "mutagenic and carcinogenic"; no intake without health risk could be set [3]
Steam (saturated or superheated)Water only; no chemical residueWater only; no chemical residueSteam at 100–200 °C; energy use, color and sensory changes, loss of volatile compounds [5]. Dried red pepper: steam at 100 °C for 16 min gave 1–2 log, gamma at 10 kGy about 5 log [5]
IrradiationUp to 30 kGy, labeled [6]Up to 10 kGy, labeled [7]In the same red-pepper study, gamma irradiation reduced capsanthin [5]

[1] 40 CFR 180.151(a), eCFR, up to date as of October 26, 2026. [2] Commission Regulation (EU) 2015/868, Annex. [3] BfR, FAQ on the health risk of ethylene oxide in food (2022). [4] European Commission, Food and Feed Crisis Coordinators meeting of October 9, 2020, summary record. [5] Rahmati E, Khoshtaghaza MH, Banakar A, Ebadi MT. Food Sci Nutr. 2022;10(3):784–799, reporting Rico et al. [6] 21 CFR 179.26. [7] Directive 1999/3/EC. The EU listed herbs and spices for irradiation because "contamination and/or infestation can no longer be treated with fumigants such as ethylene oxide" (1999/3/EC, recitals).

Hurdle

Water activity as a hurdle

Water activity is the vapor pressure of water over a product divided by that of pure water at the same temperature. Below a pathogen's minimum it cannot grow, which is why dry extracts, powders and capsules are shelf-stable without a kill step.

Low water activity stops growth, not survival, and it raises heat resistance. At 60 °C, D for S. aureus in pasta dough rose from 3 min at aw 0.92 to more than 40 min at 0.80. Salmonella Senftenberg had a D of 480 min at 70 °C in milk chocolate, against 0.56 min at 65.6 °C in milk.

No listed pathogen grows below aw 0.83; most need 0.92 or moreFDA, Appendix 4, Table A-1
Minimum water activity for growth of eight bacterial pathogens (ten entries), from 0.83 for Staphylococcus aureus to 0.97 for non-proteolytic Clostridium botulinum, with the 0.85 boundary that 21 CFR 113.3 uses to define low-acid foods0.800.850.900.951.00Minimum water activity for growth, awStaphylococcus aureus, growthStaphylococcus aureus, growth: 0.830.83S. aureus, toxin formationS. aureus, toxin formation: 0.850.85Bacillus cereusBacillus cereus: 0.920.92Listeria monocytogenesListeria monocytogenes: 0.920.92Clostridium perfringensClostridium perfringens: 0.930.93C. botulinum A, proteolytic B and FC. botulinum A, proteolytic B and F: 0.9350.935Salmonella spp.Salmonella spp.: 0.940.94Yersinia enterocoliticaYersinia enterocolitica: 0.9450.945Pathogenic E. coliPathogenic E. coli: 0.950.95C. botulinum E, non-proteolytic B and FC. botulinum E, non-proteolytic B and F: 0.970.970.85: above this (and pH above 4.6) a food is low-acid, 21 CFR 113.3(n)The lowest values reported in the cited literature, with salt as the humectant; other solutes and conditions give other limits.Minimum water activity for growth of ten bacterial pathogens, from 0.83 for S. aureus to 0.97 for non-proteolytic C. botulinum, with the 0.85 low-acid boundaryMinimum aw for growth0.800.850.900.951.00Staphylococcus aureus, growth0.83S. aureus, toxin formation0.85Bacillus cereus0.92Listeria monocytogenes0.92Clostridium perfringens0.93C. botulinum A, proteolytic B and F0.935Salmonella spp.0.94Yersinia enterocolitica0.945Pathogenic E. coli0.95C. botulinum E, non-proteolytic B and F0.97Dashed line 0.85: low-acid boundary, 21 CFR 113.3(n)
FDA, Fish and Fishery Products Hazards and Controls Guidance, Appendix 4, Table A-1 (minimum aw using salt). Low-acid boundary: 21 CFR 113.3(n). Water activity definition: 21 CFR 113.3(w). Heat resistance at low aw: ICMSF 1996 via IFT report for FDA (2000), Tables 2 and 11.
Clean-in-place

The CIP cycle

Clean-in-place circulates rinses and detergents through closed equipment in a fixed sequence: pre-rinse, caustic wash, rinse, acid rinse, sanitize, post-rinse. Alkaline cleaners remove organic soil such as protein and fat; acid cleaners remove inorganic deposits. Spray balls distribute the solutions inside vessels.

Temperature is set by the process and chemistry, concentration by the chemical supplier, and cycle time experimentally. A cycle that removes visible soil can still leave biofilm: in a laboratory study, a standard regime did not reproducibly remove bacteria attached to stainless steel.

Steps of a clean-in-place cycle with purpose, example conditions and routing of the return
StepPurposeExample conditionsReturn goes to
1 Pre-rinseRemove loose soilWaterDrain
2 Caustic washRemove organic soil (protein, fat, carbohydrate) [2]1% sodium hydroxide, 65 °C, 10 min [3]Caustic tank, for reuse
3 RinseRemove detergentWaterDrain
4 Acid rinseRemove inorganic deposits [2]1.0% nitric acid, 65 °C, 10 min [3]Acid tank, for reuse
5 SanitizeReduce surviving microorganismsA 21 CFR 178.1010 solution within its concentration limitDrain; "followed by adequate draining, before contact with food" [4]
6 Post-rinseRemove sanitizer where its use calls for itPotable waterDrain

[1] Bowser TJ. What is Clean in Place (CIP)? Oklahoma Cooperative Extension Service FAPC-251, August 2023 (sequence; settings). [2] Groten F, et al. Front Med Technol. 2025;7:1540779. [3] Bremer PJ, Fillery S, McQuillan AJ. Int J Food Microbiol. 2006;106(3):254–262: the "standard" laboratory regime, which did not reproducibly remove biofilm. [4] 21 CFR 178.1010(a).

Tanks, a supply pump and a heat exchanger feed a spray ball; conductivity and temperature on the return decide whether each phase goes to drain or back to its tankSchematic, not to scale
Three-dimensional rendering of a clean-in-place circuit: rinse-water, caustic and acid tanks, supply pump, steam heat exchanger, sanitizer dosing, a process vessel cut away to show the spray ball, return pump, divert valve and floor drain.
  1. 1 Rinse water
  2. 2 Caustic
  3. 3 Acid
  4. 4 Supply pump
  5. 5 Heat exchanger (steam)
  6. 6 Sanitizer dosing
  7. 7 Process vessel, spray ball
  8. 8 Return pump
  9. 9 Divert valve

3D rendering by EUTECNIQ, schematic. The drawing below gives the details, values and sources. EUTECNIQ has no equipment yet.

Schematic of a generic clean-in-place circuit: rinse-water, caustic and acid supply tanks feed a supply header and a supply pump; a heat exchanger heated by steam raises the solution temperature; a sanitizer dosing pump joins the supply line, which carries flow, temperature and conductivity transmitters before entering the top of a process vessel through a static spray ball; the vessel drains to a return pump; temperature and conductivity are measured on the return line, and a divert valve sends each phase either to the floor drain through an air gap or back along a return header to its own tank. A strip below lists the six steps of the cycle.
Cycle steps, the 1.5 m/s velocity rule, conductivity monitoring and riboflavin coverage testing: Bowser TJ, Oklahoma Cooperative Extension FAPC-251 (August 2023). Example caustic and acid conditions: Bremer PJ, et al. Int J Food Microbiol. 2006;106(3):254–262. Spray balls and cleaner chemistry: Groten F, et al. Front Med Technol. 2025;7:1540779. Air gap: 21 CFR 111.15(f)(5). Illustration by EUTECNIQ. Full-size SVG
Mechanical action

Turbulence and the Sinner circle

Sinner's circle names four factors that trade against one another in cleaning: time, temperature, mechanical action and chemical action; an extended version adds the surface being cleaned. In pipelines the mechanical action is turbulence, and a velocity of at least 1.5 m/s (5 ft/s) keeps the flow turbulent. The table converts that velocity into the flow a supply pump must deliver.

Flow and Reynolds number in a full pipeQ = v × πD2/4   Re = ρvD/μ   water: ρ 998.3 kg/m³, μ 1.002 mPa·s at 20 °C; ρ 977.8 kg/m³, μ 0.404 mPa·s at 70 °C
Flow rate and Reynolds number at 1.5 meters per second for five inside diameters
Inside diameter (mm)Flow at 1.5 m/s (L/min)Flow (m³/h)Re, water at 20 °CRe, water at 70 °C
2544.22.6537,40090,900
381026.1256,800138,000
5017710.674,800182,000
7539823.9112,000273,000
10070742.4150,000363,000

Computed. Water properties: IAPWS-95 via CoolProp 8.0.0 at 200 kPa. Velocity rule: Bowser TJ, FAPC-251 (2023). Sinner's circle: Groten F, et al. Front Med Technol. 2025;7:1540779. For comparison, 21 CFR 179.39 sets a minimum Reynolds number of 2,200 for turbulent flow in UV treatment of juice. A larger line at the same pump flow runs slower; check the velocity in every branch as well as at the pump.

Verification

Verifying a clean

FDA's draft allergen guidance lists visual inspection, ATP swabs, protein swabs and allergen-specific test kits on surfaces or in the final CIP rinse. ATP occurs in all living cells, so ATP and total-protein tests are non-specific and "may not be sensitive enough to detect levels of a particular allergenic protein".

Methods can disagree. In an avocado packing plant, visual scores, ATP and microbial counts often gave contradictory results, and no surface reached the expected 3-log reduction.

Cleaning verification methods: what each detects and its limitation
MethodWhat it showsLimitation
In-line conductivityDetergent concentration, measured continuously [1]Says nothing about soil or microorganisms left on the surface
Temperature recordThe solution reached its set point; a CIP that missed its target temperature is a deviation to correct [2]Temperature at the sensor, not at every surface
Riboflavin coverage testWhere a spray device wets the surface [1]Coverage, not cleanliness
ATP bioluminescenceATP from food, microorganisms or skin [2, 3]Non-specific; ATP can hydrolyze to ADP and AMP, which the test does not read [3]
Protein swabAny protein [2]Non-specific; may miss a particular allergen [2]
Allergen-specific kitA named allergenic protein, on a swab, in final rinse water or in push-through material [2]Only where a kit exists for that allergen in that matrix [2]
Microbial swab or countIndicator organisms, e.g., aerobic count, Enterobacteriaceae, Listeria spp. [4]Did not track ATP or visual scores in a packing-plant study [4]

[1] Bowser TJ, FAPC-251 (2023). [2] FDA, Hazard Analysis and Risk-Based Preventive Controls for Human Food: Draft Guidance, Chapter 11, Food Allergen Program (September 2023), § 11.6.1 and footnote 21; draft, not for implementation. [3] Bakke M. J Food Prot. 2022;85(7):1079–1095. [4] Muñiz-Flores JA, et al. J Food Prot. 2025;88(10):100593.

Sanitizers

Sanitizers and their limits

A sanitizer reduces microorganisms on a surface that is already clean; EPA describes sanitizers as reducing, "but not necessarily" eliminating, microorganisms. Solutions listed in 21 CFR 178.1010 may be used on food-processing equipment within the caps in paragraph (c), followed by adequate draining before contact with food. In the biofilm study above, adding a sanitizer step did not improve removal.

U.S. regulatory status and concentration limits of common food-contact sanitizers
AgentU.S. listingLimit when ready to use
Hypochlorite (sodium, potassium, calcium)21 CFR 178.1010(b)(1)Not more than 200 ppm available halogen as available chlorine
Chlorinated isocyanurates178.1010(b)(2)Not more than 100 ppm available chlorine
Iodine formulations (iodophors)178.1010(b)(4)–(6), (8)Not more than 25 ppm titratable iodine
Quaternary ammonium, n-alkyl (C12–C18) benzyldimethylammonium chloride178.1010(b)(9)Not more than 200 ppm active quaternary compound
Peroxyacetic acid with hydrogen peroxide, acetic and sulfuric acids178.1010(b)(38); also on dairy equipmentPeroxyacetic acid 200–315 ppm; hydrogen peroxide 300–465 ppm
Ozone21 CFR 173.368, antimicrobial in gas or water phaseGood manufacturing practice; Food Chemicals Codex specification
Hydrogen peroxide (packaging sterilant)21 CFR 178.1005Solution at most 35%; at most 0.5 ppm in water packaged under production conditions

eCFR, 21 CFR 173.368, 178.1005 and 178.1010(a)–(c), up to date as of October 26, 2026. U.S. EPA, What are antimicrobial pesticides? (updated January 29, 2026), which counts more than 4,000 registered antimicrobial products. Bremer PJ, et al. 2006. Each paragraph of 178.1010 lists a specific formulation; a product's label and listing, not the active ingredient's name, decide whether it qualifies.

21 CFR Part 111

Sanitation rules for supplements

Dietary supplement manufacturing follows 21 CFR Part 111; a facility that complies with it is exempt from the preventive-controls subparts C and G of Part 117 for that work. Part 111's sanitation sections set required outcomes, written procedures and records rather than chemistries or temperatures.

Sanitation requirements of 21 CFR Part 111 subparts B, C and D
SectionRequirement
111.10 (Subpart B, personnel)Exclude anyone who may be a source of microbial contamination; wash hands before work and when soiled; intact, impermeable gloves; hair restraints; no eating, drinking or tobacco where materials or contact surfaces are exposed
111.15(c) (Subpart C, plant)Cleaning compounds and sanitizing agents free from microorganisms of public health significance, and safe and adequate under the conditions of use
111.15(e), 111.23(c)Water that may become a component meets Federal, State and local requirements, with records to show it
111.15(f)(5)No backflow or cross-connection between waste piping and piping that carries manufacturing or cleaning water
111.15(k)One or more sanitation supervisors qualified by education, training or experience
111.16, 111.23(b)Written, followed procedures for cleaning the physical plant and for pest control, and records of them
111.20(c)(5), (d)Separate or defined areas for cleaning and sanitizing contact surfaces; floors, walls and ceilings that can be kept clean
111.27(a) (Subpart D, equipment)Equipment installed for cleaning, corrosion-resistant and nontoxic, with smoothly bonded seams; instruments that control temperature, pH or water activity accurate and maintained
111.27(d)Clean and sanitize contact surfaces as necessary, taking equipment apart as needed; low-moisture surfaces dry and sanitary in use; for wet processing, clean and sanitize before use and after any interruption
111.25(c), 111.35(b)(2)Written procedures for maintaining, cleaning and sanitizing equipment; equipment logs of the date of use, maintenance, cleaning and sanitizing, unless kept in the batch record

eCFR, 21 CFR 111.10, 111.15, 111.16, 111.20, 111.23, 111.25, 111.27, 111.35 and 117.5(e), up to date as of October 26, 2026. Summaries; the regulation text governs.

Proposed

Where EUTECNIQ would work

Proposed EUTECNIQ would choose a kill step per product from validated data, design pilot equipment for clean-in-place with logged conductivity and temperature, and keep cleaning and sanitizing records as Part 111 requires. It has no facility, equipment or validated process yet.

Related: Microorganisms and their detection · Scale-up and tech transfer · Quality system · Drying and particle engineering

Health information notice

These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Nothing on this site is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. The information is for general education only. It is not medical advice and does not replace advice, diagnosis or treatment from a qualified health professional, or any medication a clinician has prescribed.

Do not start, stop or change any medicine, supplement or herbal product because of something you read here. Talk to your doctor or pharmacist first, especially if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, have a medical condition, take any medicines, are preparing for surgery, or are caring for a child. Research findings, traditional uses and safety data are reported as their sources state them; they are not recommendations or claims about any product. If you think you may have a medical emergency, call your doctor or 911 at once.

EUTECNIQ Sciences sells no supplements or health products today and receives nothing from any product or ingredient mentioned on this site; any commercial interest it later has in an ingredient will be stated on that ingredient’s page.

Ready to check what you take?

Free tools built on published reference values, each with its sources and its limits. Your lists stay in your browser.