EUTECNIQ Sciences

See every page on one mapArrow keys move through results · Enter opens · Esc closes

Platform · Traceable supply chain Part A: sourced facts Part B: proposal

A ledger can prove a record is unchanged, not that the plant in the drum matches it

A botanical changes owner, form and customs code several times before it reaches a capsule, and each handoff can substitute, contaminate or relabel it. Part A sets out what is documented and what current rules, standards and pilots do. Part B is EUTECNIQ's proposal: tie each lot's record to physical evidence, then make every later edit visible.

20.0%of 2,235 commercial turmeric samples in 48 publications were adulterated (pooled surveys, not a market estimate)
7critical tracking events in the FSMA 204 food traceability rule
Jul 20, 2028Public Law 119-37 bars funds for enforcing FSMA 204 before this date; FDA's extension rule is still a proposal
2.2 sto trace mangoes to their farm in Walmart's pilot, against almost 7 days by phone and email (company-reported; no method published)

Status. EUTECNIQ operates no ledger, software, laboratory or supply chain and has no partners or customers for one. Part B describes a proposed design; it does not exist and is not in use. The timeline and the hash demonstration use invented lots and records.

Related, not repeated here: Digital lab (Part 11, lot genealogy, FSMA 204 data elements, a live hash chain) · Data asset (four record designs compared) · Global trade data · Botanical identity · Certificate-of-analysis science · A good sample is not a reliable supply

What traceability is for Part 111 requirements Proposal

Traceability pays off in four decisions: which supplier, which lot, where a defect entered, and whether a new lot matches the old

Each decision needs a record that links a physical lot to its evidence. Part 111 already requires most of these records; the proposal on this page would add evidence anchored upstream, before the material changes hands.

Four decisions, the traced record that answers each, and what happens without it
DecisionTraced record that answers itWithout it
Procurement: qualify a supplier and decide whether to rely on its certificateIdentity results confirmed across several of that supplier's lots; a certificate relied on only under the five conditions of 21 CFR 111.75(a)(2)(ii). Proposed: voucher specimen, DNA barcode and pre-shipment fingerprint, anchored before shipmentThe buyer relies on a claim it cannot check. Substitution is documented at every stage from field to shelf; in pooled surveys, 20.0% of 2,235 commercial turmeric samples were adulterated
Release: accept or reject a received lotThe manufacturer's identity test of the bulk against the botanical reference and the anchored pre-shipment fingerprint; the marker assay against the certificate, within the uncertainty of both results (111.75(a)(1)(i), 111.155(c))Quality control can still fail the lot, but cannot tell whether the gap arose in the supplier's sampling or in the bulk, and a supplier record could be revised afterwards without the change being visible
Investigation and recall: find where a defect entered and which finished lots to holdEach component lot traced to its supplier and to the supplement made from it (111.155(d)(1)); component lot identifiers in each batch record (111.260(d)); distribution records (111.475)Records move one step at a time, firm by firm. Walmart reported almost 7 days to trace mangoes to their farm by phone and email, against 2.2 seconds on its ledger pilot (company-reported; no method published)
Comparability: decide whether a new lot, source or extract batch matches the one qualifiedFingerprint and marker assay compared with the anchored record of the qualified material; a mass balance of extract shipped against plant material consumed at the declared drug-to-extract ratio (proposed)A change of origin or process stays invisible until a test fails. Ginsenoside Rb1 in 6-year ginseng roots varied about twofold between regions, and marker content in 25 ginseng products varied 15- to 200-fold

The tests decide; the record decides which test result belongs to which lot, and whether it was written before the question arose. No check releases or rejects a lot by itself: quality control decides (§ 111.155(c)).

21 CFR 111.75 and 111.155 (eCFR version of October 1, 2026); 21 CFR 111.260(d) and 111.475, as cited on Quality system; Gafner et al., Pharm Biol 2026 (turmeric scoping review); Xiao et al., J Ginseng Res 2015; Harkey et al., Am J Clin Nutr 2001; Kamath 2018 and LF Decentralized Trust, Walmart case study. Full citations in the sections below and under References. The anchored records are EUTECNIQ's proposal; no system exists.

Four decisions, and the traced record that answers eachSchematic · content from this page
Hub diagram. Center: traced record. Four decisions: procurement, release, investigation and recall, comparability, each with the record that answers it and the cited Part 111 section or published figure.
Content from this section: 21 CFR 111.75, 111.155, 111.260(d), 111.475; Gafner et al., Pharm Biol 2026; Harkey et al., Am J Clin Nutr 2001. Drawn by EUTECNIQ. Full-size SVG
Part A · Where the record breaks

Plants and extracts cross borders under different customs codes, and no public record links the two

Plant material (HS 12.11) into five processing countries, and their saps and extracts (HS 13.02) into the United States, 2024, US$ millionUN Comtrade
35.5%of 2024 U.S. HS 13.02 imports came from the five countries drawn (US$595.2M of 1,678.8M)
Show data: the flow table
HS 12.11 imports of five countries and their HS 13.02 exports to the United States, 2024, US$ million
CountryHS 12.11 imports from other countriesThree largest originsU.S. HS 13.02 imports from itShare of U.S. HS 13.02, %
China337.4Viet Nam 68.1; Canada 46.6; Myanmar 43.1359.921.4
Germany504.5Canada 90.1; India 78.9; Poland 39.269.44.1
France141.5Germany 19.0; India 18.6; Morocco 12.1128.97.7
Japan335.2China 279.1; South Africa 13.4; India 10.014.60.9
Korea, Rep.129.3China 90.9; India 9.5; Indonesia 4.222.41.3
All U.S. HS 13.02 imports—85 partners; India 497.6 (29.6%)1,678.8100.0

Stage 1 values are reported by each importing country; stage 2 values are reported by the United States. Origins sending US$20 million or more to one of the five countries are drawn separately; all others are grouped as other origins.

The two stages are different commodities. Customs data do not show whether the imported plants became the exported extracts, which plants a flow contains, or which lots it carried. In 2024, pectic substances, agar and other mucilages and thickeners (HS 1302.20 to 1302.39) were US$512.4M, 30.5% of U.S. HS 13.02 imports; the partner data drawn here are at heading level and do not separate them. India, the largest U.S. supplier of HS 13.02, is not drawn because its plant imports were not compiled.UN Comtrade Database, HS 1211 (importer-reported) and U.S. HS 1302 imports by partner, annual 2024; public API, retrieved October 22, 2026, as compiled for Global trade data; generated

Customs statistics count value and weight by heading and country. They carry no lot codes, so tracing a botanical from field to capsule needs records the trading partners keep themselves.

How the chart was built, and what customs data cannot show

HS 12.11 covers "plants and parts of plants (including seeds and fruits), of a kind used primarily in perfumery, in pharmacy or for insecticidal, fungicidal or similar purposes, fresh, chilled, frozen or dried, whether or not cut, crushed or powdered". HS 13.02 covers "vegetable saps and extracts; pectic substances, pectinates and pectates; agar-agar and other mucilages and thickeners, whether or not modified, derived from vegetable products". A plant and an extract made from it therefore fall under different headings, and the chart links them only through the countries that trade both.

The five middle countries are the five largest U.S. suppliers of HS 13.02 among the 7 importers other than the United States compiled on the global trade page; the others, Hong Kong SAR (US$0.2M) and Other Asia, n.e.s. (US$3.0M), are not drawn. Values are importer-reported primary values; importers mostly report CIF, exporters FOB, and mirror figures differ, as the global trade page explains. Japan imports large volumes of Chinese plant material but supplies little HS 13.02 to the United States; the chart shows both facts and implies nothing about what happens in between.

Heading texts: World Customs Organization, HS Nomenclature 2022 Edition, headings 12.11 and 13.02 (as also listed in the UN Comtrade HS reference file).

Part A · Where failures are documented

Substitution, contamination and mislabeling are documented at every stage from field to shelf

Supply-chain stage by failure mode: select a cell to read what the evidence shows and its sourceEditorial evidence map
Evidence level for each supply-chain stage and failure mode. Each cell is a button that shows the rationale and sources below the table.
StageSubstitutionContaminationMislabelingSample-vs-bulk gap
Farm or wild collection
Aggregator and primary processor
Extractor
Supplement manufacturer
Brand and market

Select a cell.

The rationale and its sources appear here. All 20 are also listed in the table below.

Text version: all 20 cells with rationale and sources
Rationale and sources for each cell of the evidence map
Stage and failure modeLevelRationaleSources
Farm or wild collection · SubstitutionNamed control pointWHO GACP asks growers to verify and record the botanical identity of each cultivated plant, with a voucher specimen where identity is in doubt (section 2.1), and asks collectors to prepare voucher specimens for herbarium authentication (section 3.3). No source cited here measures substitution rates at harvest.World Health Organization
Farm or wild collection · ContaminationDocumented hereAt 37 wolfberry sites in Ningxia, cadmium was concentrated in the fruit relative to its root-zone soil (bioconcentration factor 5.82) and exceeded the standard limit in fruit at one site. WHO GACP addresses soil and fertilizers (section 2.3.4) and the quality of irrigation water (section 2.3.5).Zhou T, Wang Y, Qin J, Zhao S, Cao D, Zhu M, Jiang Y; World Health Organization
Farm or wild collection · MislabelingCarried throughNo source cited here places labeling errors at harvest. The name a collector uses travels with the lot until an identity test checks it.No stage-specific source
Farm or wild collection · Sample-vs-bulk gapDocumented hereIn ginseng roots aged 3 to 6 years from three regions, ginsenosides Rg1 and Re rose with age, and Rb1 in 6-year roots varied about twofold between regions. The study did not test pooled lots; that one field's sample need not describe a lot pooled from several is an inference from this variation.Xiao D, Yue H, Xiu Y, Sun X, Wang Y, Liu S
Aggregator and primary processor · SubstitutionDocumented hereIn 48 publications covering 2,235 commercial turmeric samples, 20.0% were adulterated, and 20.4% of spice samples. Reported adulterants include artificial dyes, undeclared diluents and synthetic curcumin. The samples were commercial products, so the stage at which adulterants entered is inferred.Gafner S, Orhan N, Kahraman Ç, Blumenthal M
Aggregator and primary processor · ContaminationDocumented hereIn Bangladesh, a field study found evidence of lead chromate pigment adulteration of turmeric in 7 of the 9 major producing districts; polishers added the pigment to dried turmeric root. In a 2025 Salmonella outbreak, FDA traceback identified a single lot from a direct importer of moringa leaf powder.Forsyth JE, Nurunnahar S, Islam SS, et al; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
Aggregator and primary processor · MislabelingDocumented hereTrade names can cover several genera: EMA states that the name Fang ji can describe the roots of Aristolochia fangchi, Stephania tetrandra or Cocculus species.European Medicines Agency (EMEA), Herbal Medicinal Products Working Party
Aggregator and primary processor · Sample-vs-bulk gapNamed control pointEU rules adopted in 2006 described aflatoxins as very heterogeneously distributed in a lot and sampled spice lots of 15 metric tons or more in sublots of 25 metric tons with 100 increments each. Codex warns that no sampling plan can ensure that every item in a lot conforms.Commission Regulation (EC) No 401/2006 of 23 February 2006 laying down the methods of sampling and analysis for the official control of the levels of mycotoxins in foodstuffs, recital 7 and Annex I part E (text as adopted; repealed from April 1, 2024).; Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2023/2782 of 14 December 2023 laying down the methods of sampling and analysis for the control of the levels of mycotoxins in food and repealing Regulation (EC) No 401/2006 (applies from April 1, 2024).; Codex Alimentarius Commission
Extractor · SubstitutionDocumented hereSurveys found 9 of 21 grape seed extract products and 3 of 8 ginkgo products adulterated; the adulterants were peanut skin extract and added free flavonol aglycones, materials of the kind added during extract manufacture. The surveys tested finished products, so the stage is inferred.Villani TS, Reichert W, Ferruzzi MG, Pasinetti GM, Simon JE, Wu Q; Wohlmuth H, Savage K, Dowell A, Mouatt P
Extractor · ContaminationNamed control pointICH Q3C, a pharmaceutical guideline whose scope is drug substances, excipients and drug products, sets limits for residual solvents, which it defines as organic volatile chemicals used or produced in manufacture; solvent extraction is where such solvents would enter a botanical extract. The certificate-of-analysis course explains the classes and limits.ICH
Extractor · MislabelingDocumented hereThe ABC–AHP–NCNPR program documents ingredients substituted, diluted or "fortified" with undisclosed lower-cost ingredients, often by schemes designed to deceive the analytical methods used for authentication.Gafner S, Blumenthal M, Foster S, Cardellina JH 2nd, Khan IA, Upton R
Extractor · Sample-vs-bulk gapCarried throughNo source cited here documents a sample-vs-bulk gap specific to extracts. Extract batches combine raw-material lots, which is why each received lot is sampled again.No stage-specific source
Supplement manufacturer · SubstitutionDocumented hereIn weight-reducing pills taken by the patients Nortier et al. studied in Brussels, Stephania tetrandra was inadvertently replaced by Aristolochia fangchi because of a manufacturing error. In FY2025, FDA's published inspection observations include 66 citing the identity-test requirement for dietary ingredients (111.75(a)(1)(i)).Nortier JL, Martinez MC, Schmeiser HH, et al; FDA
Supplement manufacturer · ContaminationNamed control pointPart 111 requires limits on the types of contamination that may adulterate each component and the finished batch (21 CFR 111.70(b) and (e)).21 CFR 111.70, What specifications must you establish? eCFR, current as of October 28, 2026.
Supplement manufacturer · MislabelingNamed control pointPart 111 requires finished-batch specifications for identity, purity, strength and composition (21 CFR 111.70(e)); citations of 111.70(e) rose from 1.4% of Part 111 inspection observations in FY2010 to 9.7% in FY2025.21 CFR 111.70, What specifications must you establish? eCFR, current as of October 28, 2026.; FDA
Supplement manufacturer · Sample-vs-bulk gapNamed control pointPart 111 requires representative samples of each unique shipment and each unique lot within it (111.80(a)), and quarantine until quality control has reviewed the results and approved the component for use (111.155(c)); a supplier's sample does not replace them.21 CFR 111.80, What representative samples must you collect? eCFR (version of October 1, 2026, read October 30, 2026).; 21 CFR 111.155, What requirements apply to components of dietary supplements? eCFR (version of October 1, 2026, read October 30, 2026).
Brand and market · SubstitutionDocumented hereOf 37 St. John's wort dry extracts, finished products and bulk herb samples, selected because preliminary tests suggested adulteration, HPTLC showed synthetic dyes in 8 and non-conforming flavonoid fingerprints in 6. In Echinacea products marketed across Europe, DNA metabarcoding detected no Echinacea in 4 of the 38 products retained for analysis.Frommenwiler DA, Reich E, Sudberg S, Sharaf MHM, Bzhelyansky A, Lucas B; Raclariu AC, Țebrencu CE, Ichim MC, Ciupercǎ OT, Brysting AK, de Boer H
Brand and market · ContaminationDocumented here14 of 70 Ayurvedic products bought near Boston contained lead, mercury and/or arsenic. In 2023–2024, lead in cinnamon used in applesauce pouches was linked to 566 cases in the United States.Saper RB, Kales SN, Paquin J, et al; Troeschel AN, Buser MC, Winquist A, et al
Brand and market · MislabelingDocumented hereIn 25 ginseng products from one U.S. health food store, all were correctly identified as Panax or Eleutherococcus, but marker content differed significantly from labeled amounts, and marker concentrations varied 15- to 200-fold between products.Harkey MR, Henderson GL, Gershwin ME, Stern JS, Hackman RM
Brand and market · Sample-vs-bulk gapCarried throughA buyer who tests one retail lot learns about that lot. Part 111 places finished-batch sampling with the manufacturer (111.80(c)); the sources cited here report product-to-product rather than retail lot-to-lot data.21 CFR 111.80, What representative samples must you collect? eCFR (version of October 1, 2026, read October 30, 2026).
11 of 20 cells are documented by a case, survey or dataset; 6 rest on a regulation or guideline; 3 have no stage-specific source. The level describes the evidence, not how often a failure occurs; surveys used small, non-random samples and are not market prevalence estimates. Stage 2 includes drying, polishing, milling and trading.Sources per cell in the text version. Editorial classification by EUTECNIQ from the cited literature, October 2026.

Every stage has at least one documented failure, so a record that starts at the manufacturer's dock starts too late.

The adulteration evidence base and the identity rules, in brief

The ABC–AHP–NCNPR Botanical Adulterants Prevention Program was founded by the American Botanical Council in 2011, in partnership with consortium members; its partners include the American Herbal Pharmacopoeia and the University of Mississippi's National Center for Natural Products Research. As of early March 2021 it had published 63 peer-reviewed documents, including 22 bulletins and 10 laboratory guidance documents (later counts not verified here). Its 2023 review describes ingredients "intentionally substituted, diluted, or 'fortified' with undisclosed lower-cost ingredients", often by schemes designed to deceive the analytical methods used for authentication. Survey results and the methods that catch each scheme: botanical identity course.

Under 21 CFR Part 111 a manufacturer must conduct at least one appropriate test or examination to verify the identity of every component that is a dietary ingredient, unless FDA grants a petition for an exemption (§ 111.75(a)(1)(i)–(ii)), sample each unique shipment and each lot within it (§ 111.80(a)), and may rely on a supplier's certificate for other components only under five conditions (§ 111.75(a)(2)(ii)(A)–(E)). The rule and the sampling statistics behind it: a good sample is not a reliable supply. Reading the certificate itself: certificate-of-analysis science.

ABC press release, March 9, 2021; Gafner et al., J Nat Prod 2023;86(2):460–472; 21 CFR 111.75 and 111.80 (eCFR version of October 1, 2026).

Part A · Existing rules and standards

Current rules trace records one step at a time, and only Part 111 tests the material itself

Five traceability systems compared: scope, unit traced, records and whether anyone tests the materialStatutes, regulations and standards
Comparison of 21 CFR Part 111, FSMA 204, DSCSA, GS1 EPCIS 2.0 and published blockchain pilots
SystemLegal forceCovers dried botanicals or supplementsUnit tracedRecords exchangedTests what the material is
21 CFR Part 111 (dietary supplement cGMP)Regulation, in forceYesEach component lot, traced to its supplier and to the supplement made from it (§ 111.155(d)(1))Kept by each firm; available to FDA on request (§ 111.610)Yes: an identity test of every dietary ingredient, unless FDA grants an exemption
FSMA 204 Food Traceability RuleRegulation; enforcement barred before July 20, 2028 (Pub. L. 119-37)Only foods on the Food Traceability List, whose herb entry covers fresh herbsTraceability lotKey data elements for 7 critical tracking events; records to FDA within 24 hours of a request, as an electronic sortable spreadsheet when FDA asks during an outbreak, recall or other public-health threatNo
Drug Supply Chain Security Act (DSCSA)Statute, 2013No: prescription drugs in finished dosage formPackage: National Drug Code plus serial number, lot and expiryInteroperable, electronic tracing at the package levelNo: it identifies and traces packages
GS1 EPCIS 2.0Voluntary standard, ratified June 2022If trading partners adopt itObject, lot or quantity (GTIN with lot), at a location (GLN)Events: what, when, where, why, how; JSON or XML, REST interfaceNo: it records observations
Published blockchain pilotsVoluntaryPilots named mangoes and porkAs each pilot defined itEvents and uploaded certificates on a shared ledgerNo: it stores what participants enter
21 CFR 111.75, 111.155 and 111.610 (eCFR version of October 1, 2026); FDA FSMA 204 page (content current as of October 8, 2026) and Food Traceability List; Pub. L. 119-37, § 780; Pub. L. 113-54; FDA DSCSA page (current as of October 16, 2025); 21 U.S.C. 360eee(13), (14), (20); GS1 EPCIS 2.0 (June 2022); 21 CFR 1.1455; FDA small business dispenser exemption letter (July 12, 2024); Kamath 2018; LF Decentralized Trust Walmart case study.

The tracing rules move records between partners; Part 111's identity test is the only step that examines the material, and it happens once, at the manufacturer.

FSMA 204, DSCSA and GS1 in more detail, with dates

FSMA 204 Regulation

The rule applies to persons who manufacture, process, pack or hold foods on the Food Traceability List, domestic and foreign. FDA states that its core requirement is to "maintain records containing Key Data Elements (KDEs) associated with specific Critical Tracking Events (CTEs)": harvesting, cooling (before initial packing), initial packing, first land-based receiving, shipping, receiving and transformation. Records must be kept "as original paper or electronic records or true copies" (21 CFR 1.1455(a)(1)).

Compliance date, as of October 30, 2026. The 2022 final rule set January 20, 2026. FDA proposed extending it by 30 months to July 20, 2028 (90 FR 38084, August 7, 2025); the Federal Register shows no final rule adopting that extension. Pub. L. 119-37 (November 12, 2025), § 780, provides that no funds it appropriates "may be used to administer or enforce" the rule "prior to July 20, 2028"; FDA states that it "intends to comply with this Congressional directive". FDA's page (content current as of October 8, 2026) gives both dates: it calls January 20, 2026 the original compliance date, yet its Getting Started section still reads "The compliance date is January 20, 2026." On October 9, 2026, FDA published draft guidance on not enforcing certain requirements for certain retail food establishments and restaurants (91 FR 64629). The data elements, counted per event: digital lab.

DSCSA, for contrast Statute

Title II of the Drug Quality and Security Act (Pub. L. 113-54, November 27, 2013) "outlines steps to achieve an interoperable and electronic way to identify and trace certain prescription drugs at the package level" (FDA). Its product identifier carries the standardized numerical identifier (the National Drug Code with a serial number of up to 20 characters), lot number and expiration date (21 U.S.C. 360eee). The enhanced requirements took effect on November 27, 2023, with a one-year stabilization period; FDA exempted small business dispensers (25 or fewer full-time employees) from certain of these requirements until November 27, 2026 (FDA letter, July 12, 2024). DSCSA defines its "product" as a prescription drug in finished dosage form, so it does not reach dietary supplements.

GS1 identifiers and EPCIS 2.0 Standard

A GTIN (Global Trade Item Number) identifies a trade item; a GLN (Global Location Number) is a 13-digit key for "any location (physical, operational or legal)". EPCIS, ratified as Release 2.0 in June 2022, aims to "enable disparate applications to create and share visibility event data" through five event types: ObjectEvent, AggregationEvent, TransactionEvent, TransformationEvent and the new AssociationEvent. Release 2.0 added the "how" dimension and sensor data, JSON and JSON-LD alongside XML, and REST bindings. Its vocabulary already includes the business steps "sampling" and "inspecting", the dispositions "conformant" and "non_conformant", and a certificationInfo field.

FDA, FSMA 204 page; 21 CFR 1.1455; 90 FR 38084; Federal Register document search (October 30, 2026); 91 FR 64629; Pub. L. 119-37; Pub. L. 113-54; FDA DSCSA page; 21 U.S.C. 360eee; FDA small business dispenser exemption letter (July 12, 2024); GS1 US, What is a GTIN?; GS1 Global Location Numbers (2013); GS1 EPCIS 2.0 standard and JSON schema 2.0.1.

Part A · Blockchain pilots and their limits

Pilots made tracing faster; a ledger still stores claims and cannot check them against the physical lot

Where a ledger's guarantee starts: errors made before a record is entered pass into it unchangedSchematic
Where a ledger's guarantee starts: sampling, testing and data entry happen before the record exists, so errors there pass into the ledger unchanged; after hashing and signing, edits, swaps, gaps and reused lot codes become detectablePhysical lotbags, drums, palletsSamplingwhich units, howmanyTestingmethod, instrument,analystData entryperson, device orsystemHash and signSHA-256, digitalsignatureLedgerreplicated,append-onlybefore the record existsafter: the ledger's guaranteePasses into the ledger unchanged•A sample that does not represent the lot•A wrong, unvalidated or spiked result•A false or mistyped entry, or a sensor placed on the wrong palletBecomes detectable•A record edited after entry•A certificate swapped for another•A missing or out-of-order event•A lot code used twiceSampling plans, validated methods, trained analysts and second-person review control the left side; hashing and signatures control the right.Where a ledger's guarantee starts, phone layoutPhysical lotbags, drums, palletsSamplingwhich units, how manyTestingmethod, instrument, analystData entryperson, device or systemHash and signSHA-256, digital signatureLedgerreplicated, append-onlyBefore hashing: passes in unchanged•A sample that does not represent the lot•A wrong, unvalidated or spiked result•A false or mistyped entry, or a sensor placed on thewrong palletAfter hashing: becomes detectable•A record edited after entry•A certificate swapped for another•A missing or out-of-order event•A lot code used twiceSampling plans, validated methods and review control thefirst part; hashing and signatures the second.
NIST IR 8202 (2018), sections 7.1 and 7.3; Caldarelli, Information 2020;11:509; Kamilaris et al., Trends Food Sci Technol 2019;91:640–652 (as read in the arXiv preprint); Powell et al., J Ind Inf Integr 2022;25:100261.
Text version of the schematic

A physical lot is sampled, the sample is tested, and a person, device or system enters the result. Only then is the record hashed, signed and written to the ledger. Errors before that point pass into the ledger unchanged: a sample that does not represent the lot, a wrong, unvalidated or spiked result, a false or mistyped entry, or a sensor on the wrong pallet. After it, the ledger makes a record edited after entry, a certificate swapped for another, a missing or out-of-order event and a reused lot code detectable. Sampling plans, validated methods, trained analysts and second-person review control the first part; hashing and signatures the second.

Of 49 blockchain projects in agriculture and food surveyed in 2019, 4 were integrated into normal operationsPreprint counts
Bar chart: of 49 blockchain projects in agriculture and food surveyed by Kamilaris et al. (2019), conceptual stage 10; implementation phase 13; proof of concept, small pilot 14; large-scale case study 8; full integration into operations 4Conceptual stageConceptual stage: 10 of 49 (20%)10 of 49Implementation phaseImplementation phase: 13 of 49 (27%)13 of 49Proof of concept, small pilotProof of concept, small pilot: 14 of 49 (29%)14 of 49Large-scale case studyLarge-scale case study: 8 of 49 (16%)8 of 49Full integration into operationsFull integration into operations: 4 of 49 (8%)4 of 49Bar chart: of 49 blockchain projects in agriculture and food surveyed by Kamilaris et al. (2019), conceptual stage 10; implementation phase 13; proof of concept, small pilot 14; large-scale case study 8; full integration into operations 4Conceptual stageConceptual stage: 10 of 49 (20%)10 of 49Implementation phaseImplementation phase: 13 of 49 (27%)13 of 49Proof of concept, smallpilotProof of concept, small pilot: 14 of 49 (29%)14 of 49Large-scale case studyLarge-scale case study: 8 of 49 (16%)8 of 49Full integration intooperationsFull integration into operations: 4 of 49 (8%)4 of 49
Kamilaris A, Fonts A, Prenafeta-Boldú FX. Trends Food Sci Technol 2019;91:640–652. Counts are taken from the authors' arXiv preprint (arXiv:1908.07391, August 2019; not peer reviewed), section 4 and Figure 4; the published version, which the preprint states appeared in this journal, was not reviewed, so its counts are not confirmed here. 41 of the 49 projects started in 2016 to 2018, which the authors say made their assessment difficult.
Show data
Maturity of blockchain projects in agriculture and food, Kamilaris et al. 2019
Maturity levelProjects
Conceptual stage10 (20.4%)
Implementation phase13 (26.5%)
Proof of concept, small pilot14 (28.6%)
Large-scale case study8 (16.3%)
Full integration into operations4 (8.2%)
Total49

What the most cited pilot reported, and what the sources leave out

What the most cited pilot reported, and what the sources leave out
PilotReported resultNot reported
Walmart and IBM, sliced mangoes (U.S.), on Hyperledger FabricTracing a package to its farm took "almost seven days" by phone and email; on the ledger it took 2.2 secondsA method for the comparison, or any check that the recorded farm was the true source
Walmart and IBM, pork (China)Certificates of authenticity uploaded to the ledger (LF Decentralized Trust); Kamath describes IBM's platform records as "logged in real time and permanently stored as e-certificates" and the pork chain's tags, cameras and truck sensorsQuantitative results or failures
Follow-onOver 25 products from 5 suppliers traceable; Walmart announced it would require its fresh leafy-greens suppliers to joinIndependent evaluation

LF Decentralized Trust (formerly Hyperledger Foundation), Walmart case study (undated web page, read October 30, 2026); Kamath R, J Br Blockchain Assoc 2018;1(1), a case study drawing on published reports and on interviews with IBM and Walmart representatives.

The documented gain is speed of retrieval. Whether the retrieved record was true still depended on what participants entered.

Six known limits, each with its source
The oracle problem
Blockchains "must rely on external systems to obtain accurate information from the real-world", which Kamilaris et al. call oracles: sensors, software and "manual records (i.e. human oracles)". Caldarelli defines the risk of oracles "feeding the blockchain with false information" as the oracle problem, and notes that in supply chains the oracles belong to the company whose goods are tracked. NIST: there "may be no method to determine if the input data reflects real world events".
Immutability is relative
NIST: blockchain ledgers "are tamper evident and tamper resistant" but "cannot be considered completely immutable". In a permissioned network the owner or consortium controls who may publish, so "any number of blocks can be replaced through legitimate methods if desired by the owner or consortium".
Data entry integrity
Powell et al., reporting a beef export project that combined sensors and a blockchain, conclude that blockchain "does not resolve conventional IoT data quality issues"; data on it "may simply be immutable garbage".
Cost and adoption
Kamilaris et al. list the cost of computing and sensor equipment, small firms' difficulty adopting the technology, missing regulations and scalability among the barriers. Duan et al. name raw data manipulation and getting all stakeholders on board among five challenges.
Interoperability
A ledger helps only if partners describe events the same way. EPCIS was written to "enable disparate applications to create and share visibility event data" and works with or without a blockchain.
Privacy
On a common ledger "users can be identified by their public keys", and many food-chain actors compete with each other (Kamilaris et al.). NIST notes that permissioned networks can "selectively reveal transaction information". Four record designs compared: data asset.

Analytical chemists have proposed storing chemical analysis data in chronological order on a blockchain so that it cannot be altered afterwards (Galvez et al., 2018). Part B builds on that idea and keeps the documents themselves off the ledger.

Kamilaris et al. 2019 (arXiv preprint, section 6 and Table 2); Caldarelli 2020; NIST IR 8202 (2018), sections 2.2, 7.1 and 7.3; Powell et al. 2022 (abstract); Duan et al., Int J Environ Res Public Health 2020;17(5):1784 (abstract); GS1 EPCIS 2.0; Galvez et al., TrAC 2018;107:222–232 (abstract).

Part B · Proposal Proposed design

The proposed design anchors each lot record to physical evidence before it enters the ledger

Proposed architecture: evidence, SHA-256 digests, EPCIS 2.0 events, a permissioned ledger and checks that raise flagsProposal
Proposed traceability architecture: each stage's physical evidence is hashed with SHA-256; the digests ride on GS1 EPCIS 2.0 events stored on a permissioned ledger, documents stay encrypted with their owners, and consistency checks raise flags for people to resolve1Physical chain: the lot movesFarm or wild collectionharvest, dryingAggregator and primaryprocessorcleaning, milling, samplingExtractorextraction, concentration,dryingSupplementmanufacturerreceipt testing, blending,fillingBrandrelease, distribution2Physical evidence•Voucher specimen•DNA barcode of a fieldsample•Plot and harvest date•Retained pre-shipmentsample•HPTLC fingerprint•Moisture, aflatoxinresults•Batch record: input andoutput mass•Extract certificate:marker assay, residualsolvents•Identity test of the bulk,§ 111.75(a)(1)(i)•Certificate check•Finished-batchcertificate•Release record•Label proof•Retained samplesSHA-256SHA-256SHA-256SHA-256SHA-2563EPCIS 2.0 eventsObjectEvent: lot createdObjectEvent: sampling;AggregationEvent: packingTransformationEvent:plant-material lot in,extract lot outObjectEvent: receiving,inspecting;TransformationEventObjectEvent: shippingEach event carries GTIN and lot (what), time (when), GLN (where), business step and disposition (why), sensor data (how) and the evidence digests4Where records livePermissioned ledger•Each participant runs a node and signs its own events•Holds events and digests, never documents•Append-only: a correction is a new, linked eventEncrypted document stores, one per party•Certificates, chromatograms and sequence files stay with theirowner•Authenticated encryption; keys released by role•A random salt per document keeps digests unguessabledigest links5Consistency checks: flags for people to resolveSample vs bulkFingerprint and marker of thereceived bulk against the anchoredpre-shipment recordCertificateDigest of the document receivedequals the digest anchored at releaseMass balanceExtract shipped is consistent withplant material consumed and thedeclared extract ratioSequenceNo shipment before harvest; no lotcode used twiceA flag puts the lot on hold (quarantine, § 111.155(c)) and opens an investigation; the ledger records bothProposed traceability architecture, phone layout: for each stage, the evidence kept, its SHA-256 digest and the EPCIS event; then the ledger, the document stores and the consistency checksPer stage: evidence, digest, eventFarm or wild collectionharvest, drying•Voucher specimen•DNA barcode of a field sample•Plot and harvest dateSHA-256 digests on ObjectEvent: lot createdAggregator and primary processorcleaning, milling, sampling•Retained pre-shipment sample•HPTLC fingerprint•Moisture, aflatoxin resultsSHA-256 digests on ObjectEvent: sampling;AggregationEvent: packingExtractorextraction, concentration, drying•Batch record: input and output mass•Extract certificate: marker assay, residual solventsSHA-256 digests on TransformationEvent:plant-material lot in, extract lot outSupplement manufacturerreceipt testing, blending, filling•Identity test of the bulk, § 111.75(a)(1)(i)•Certificate check•Finished-batch certificateSHA-256 digests on ObjectEvent: receiving,inspecting; TransformationEventBrandrelease, distribution•Release record•Label proof•Retained samplesSHA-256 digests on ObjectEvent: shippingWhere records livePermissioned ledger•Each participant runs a node and signs its own events•Holds events and digests, never documents•Append-only: a correction is a new, linked eventEncrypted document stores•Certificates, chromatograms and sequence files staywith their owner•Authenticated encryption; keys released by role•A random salt per document keeps digestsunguessableConsistency checks raise flagsSample vs bulkFingerprint and marker of the received bulk against theanchored pre-shipment recordCertificateDigest of the document received equals the digest anchoredat releaseMass balanceExtract shipped is consistent with plant material consumedand the declared extract ratioSequenceNo shipment before harvest; no lot code used twiceA flag puts the lot on hold (§ 111.155(c)) and opens aninvestigation; the ledger records both.
Event types and vocabulary: GS1 EPCIS 2.0 JSON schema 2.0.1. Hash: SHA-256, NIST FIPS 180-4. Signatures: NIST FIPS 186-5. Tamper evidence, not absolute immutability: NIST IR 8202, section 7.1. Authenticated encryption, for example AES-GCM: NIST SP 800-38D. Identity test and quarantine: 21 CFR 111.75(a)(1)(i) and 111.155(c). A proposal; no system exists, and no vendor or platform has been chosen.
Text version of the architecture
  1. Physical chain. A lot moves from farm or wild collection to an aggregator and primary processor, an extractor, a supplement manufacturer and a brand.
  2. Physical evidence. Each stage keeps evidence about the material: a voucher specimen and a DNA barcode of a field sample; a retained pre-shipment sample with its HPTLC fingerprint and moisture and aflatoxin results; the extraction batch record with input and output mass and the extract's certificate (marker assay, residual solvents); the manufacturer's identity test of the bulk and its certificate check; release records, label proof and retained samples.
  3. Digests. Each evidence file is hashed with SHA-256.
  4. EPCIS 2.0 events. The digests travel in events that record what (GTIN and lot), when, where (GLN), why (business step and disposition) and how (sensor data): an ObjectEvent when the lot is created; sampling and an AggregationEvent for packing; a TransformationEvent for extraction; receiving and inspecting at the manufacturer; shipping.
  5. Where records live. A permissioned ledger, on which each participant runs a node and signs its own events, holds events and digests but never documents; corrections are new, linked events. Documents stay encrypted with their owners, keys are released by role, and a random salt per document keeps digests unguessable.
  6. Consistency checks. Four checks raise flags: sample against bulk, certificate digest, mass balance and event sequence. A flag puts the lot on hold and opens an investigation; people decide.

The design adds no new science. It would record, early and in a tamper-evident form, the evidence that Part 111 and good practice already ask firms to produce.

Design choices and why, in more detail
  • Evidence, not assertions. An event saying "identity conforms" is a claim; the digest of the HPTLC plate image and densitogram behind it lets a later reviewer confirm that the evidence they receive is the evidence recorded on that date. HPTLC and DNA barcoding answer different questions (fingerprints, DNA barcodes); DNA says nothing about marker content and is weak on processed extracts, so both are proposed upstream and chemistry downstream.
  • Digests on the ledger, documents off it. Certificates, chromatograms and supplier names are commercially sensitive. Only SHA-256 digests and event metadata would be shared; a 256-bit digest reveals nothing useful about a document that carries a random salt.
  • Standards first. EPCIS 2.0 events with GTIN, lot and GLN mean partners who do not join the ledger can still exchange the same records, and a later move to another ledger keeps the data.
  • Flags, not verdicts. No automated check releases or rejects a lot. Quality control decides, as Part 111 requires (§ 111.155(c)(2)–(3)).
Part B · Proposal Proposed design

Step through one lot's events, and see how a bulk that differs from its sample would be flagged

Nine EPCIS 2.0 events for one invented lot of turmeric rhizome, from field to finished productDemonstration, invented lot
  1. 1. Lot created at harvest. ObjectEvent, business step creating_class_instance. Evidence: voucher specimen, DNA barcode of a field sample, plot and date.
  2. 2. Shipped to the aggregator. ObjectEvent, shipping, disposition in_transit.
  3. 3. Pre-shipment sample taken and fingerprinted. ObjectEvent, sampling. Evidence: retained sample S-118, HPTLC plate and densitogram, moisture.
  4. 4. Bags packed onto a pallet. AggregationEvent, packing: the bags are linked to the pallet they travel on.
  5. 5. Extracted. TransformationEvent: 1,000 kg dried rhizome in, 205 kg dry extract out. Evidence: batch record and extract certificate.
  6. 6. Shipped to the manufacturer. ObjectEvent, shipping, with the purchase order as business transaction and the certificate digest.
  7. 7. Received and identity-tested. ObjectEvent, inspecting. The bulk's fingerprint and marker are compared with the anchored sample record; the result sets the disposition.
  8. 8. Blended and filled. TransformationEvent: extract lot in, finished lot out, with the finished-batch certificate digest.
  9. 9. Released and shipped. ObjectEvent, shipping. The brand can retrieve the whole lineage of its lot.
Text version: the receipt check in both scenarios

At event 7 the manufacturer tests the received bulk. If the fingerprint matches the botanical reference and the anchored pre-shipment sample, and the marker assay agrees with the certificate within its stated uncertainty, the inspecting event records the disposition "conformant" and quality control may release the lot. If the bulk shows zones absent from the reference and the sample and an assay 38% below the certificate, the event records "non_conformant", the lot stays in quarantine, and the supplier is asked to explain. The supplier's sample record was anchored before shipment, so changing it afterwards to match the bulk would be detectable. The ledger shows that the two records disagree; it does not say which is right. All lots, values and digests are invented for the demonstration; the digests are real SHA-256 values of the evidence descriptions shown.

Event, business-step and disposition names from the GS1 EPCIS 2.0 JSON schema (release 2.0.1). JSON is a simplified, non-normative illustration: identifiers use invented GS1 company prefixes, and fields beginning with "eut:" are proposed extension fields. Digests computed with SHA-256 (FIPS 180-4)

The flag comes from the receipt test, not from the ledger. What the ledger would add is a sample record dated before the shipment that could not be revised, once the bulk disagrees, without the change being detectable.

The three checks that would flag a sample-vs-bulk gap
  1. Identity. The bulk's HPTLC fingerprint against the botanical reference material and against the anchored pre-shipment fingerprint; a DNA barcode where the material is unprocessed. A mismatch with the reference fails identity under Part 111; a mismatch with the sample alone points to the supplier's sampling.
  2. Content. The marker assay of the bulk against the certificate value, judged with the measurement uncertainty of both results (results near a limit).
  3. Mass balance. Extract shipped against rhizome consumed, using the declared drug-to-extract ratio (DER). A supplier that ships more extract than its recorded inputs could yield at that ratio triggers a question. EMA guidance defines the native DER as the ratio of herbal substance to genuine herbal preparation.

21 CFR 111.75(a)(1)(i), 111.80(a) and 111.155(c); EMA/HMPC/CHMP/CVMP/287539/2005 Rev.1 (DER). Thresholds would be set per material in each specification; none is proposed here.

Part B · Proposal Proposed design

Each party would see the events that concern it, digests by default and documents only by key

Proposed access by role: who would see whatProposal
Proposed access rights by role and data class
RoleEvents (lot, time, place, quantity)Evidence digestsDocuments (certificates, chromatograms)Commercial terms
Each trading partnerIts own, plus one step up and one step downSame scopeIts own; others' when the owner grants a keyIts own contracts only
Brand that owns the finished lotFull lineage of its own lotsFull lineageBy key, as quality agreements provideNo
Auditor admitted by the participantsThe lots under auditThe lots under auditBy key, for the auditNo
FDAEach firm provides its records on request (§ 111.610; for listed foods, within 24 hours under FSMA 204)As part of those recordsAs part of those recordsAs the law requires
PublicA lot-status page, if the brand choosesOptional: a published final digestNoNo
21 CFR 111.610 and 1.1455(c); NIST IR 8202, section 2.2 (permissioned networks can "selectively reveal transaction information"); NIST SP 800-38D (authenticated encryption); NIST FIPS 186-5 (digital signatures). A proposed design; access rules would be set in agreements among participants.

Nothing on the shared ledger would let a competitor read a certificate or a price; it could only confirm that a document it was given is the one recorded.

Try it

Change one character of a certificate and its SHA-256 digest changes beyond recognition

Interactive calculator Change the inputs and the result updates. An educational simulation with stated inputs.

Hashing runs in your browser with the Web Crypto API; nothing is sent anywhere.

Digest of the original and of the current textIllustration, invented certificate
Original, as released
00437cf338ca5cdc6a89dbedef68de8c6a5e561c0a43ac57e57eb71eed2dadc5
Current text
computed in your browser
Hex digits that differ, of 640
Bits that differ, of 2560
Matches the released digestYes
SHA-256 as specified in NIST FIPS 180-4. The certificate, lot and values are invented. On average a one-character change flips about half of the 256 bits; the released digest shown is computed from the default text
Method, assumptions and limits: SHA-256 demonstration
What it calculates
The SHA-256 digest of the text in the box (UTF-8 encoded), the number of hexadecimal digits and of bits that differ from the digest of the original text, and whether the two digests are equal.
Equations
d = SHA-256(UTF-8(text)); bits differing = popcount(doriginal XOR dcurrent).
Assumptions
Line endings and spaces count: changing them changes the digest. A real system would fix a canonical form (for example, the released PDF's bytes) before hashing.
What it does not establish
A matching digest proves the text is the one released, not that its results are right. The original's results could still be wrong, which only validated methods, qualified analysts and review can prevent.
Verification
The original digest shown above was computed independently with a separate SHA-256 implementation from the default text; the page recomputes it in your browser on load and reports a match.
Part B · Limits of the proposal

What the proposed design would not do

  • An anchored record≠a correct result
  • A matching digest≠an authentic plant
  • A complete event history≠a representative sample
  • A ledger entry≠compliance with Part 111 or FSMA 204

The design would only work if growers, aggregators and extractors joined it and produced the evidence. No participant has agreed to do so, and its cost has not been estimated.

Working on botanical sourcing or supplier qualification?

EUTECNIQ is in formation. Early conversations help decide what a shared evidence record should cover.

Health information notice. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Nothing on this site is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease, and nothing here is medical advice.

Read the full notice

The information is for general education only. It does not replace advice, diagnosis or treatment from a qualified health professional, or any medication a clinician has prescribed. Do not start, stop or change any medicine, supplement or herbal product because of something you read here. Talk to your doctor or pharmacist first, especially if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, have a medical condition, take any medicines, are preparing for surgery, or are caring for a child. Research findings, traditional uses and safety data are reported as their sources state them; they are not recommendations or claims about any product. If you think you may have a medical emergency, call your doctor or 911 at once.

EUTECNIQ Sciences sells no supplements or health products today and receives nothing from any product or ingredient mentioned on this site; any commercial interest it later has in an ingredient will be stated on that ingredient’s page.

Ready to start a development project?

Tell us about an ingredient you want to specify, verify or license. Questions? Email [email protected]