EUTECNIQ Sciences

See every page on one mapArrow keys move through results · Enter opens · Esc closes

Platform · Demonstration 2

No extraction route wins on every objective

Take one documented separation: carnosic acid and rosmarinic acid from dried rosemary leaves. In the published studies, pressurized ethanol gave the highest extract yield and supercritical CO₂ the highest carnosic acid content. A deep eutectic solvent needs the least heat unless it must be recovered. This page computes energy and solvent loss for five routes from reference property data, and quotes yield and purity only from the studies that measured them.

Proposed capabilityDemonstration only. EUTECNIQ has run no extractions and owns no equipment. Energy and solvent figures are educational model outputs from CoolProp 8.0.0 property equations and the inputs stated on this page; yields and selectivity are quoted from the cited studies.

Five routes, per kg of dried rosemary leaf Heat plus pump work (MJ) and solvent not recovered (kg), at this page's default inputs

Energy and solvent loss of five extraction routes at default inputsPer kg of dried rosemary leaf at the page's default inputs. Hot water, 90 °C: heat and work 28.4 MJ, solvent not recovered 1.2 kg; Ethanol/water, 70 °C: heat and work 14.5 MJ, solvent not recovered 1.2 kg; Pressurized ethanol/water, 150 °C: heat and work 15.1 MJ, solvent not recovered 1.2 kg; Supercritical CO₂ + 5% ethanol: heat and work 5.8 MJ, solvent not recovered 1.0 kg; DES, extract left in solvent: heat and work 1.8 MJ, solvent not recovered 20.0 kg; DES, 90% recovered with water: heat and work 48.5 MJ, solvent not recovered 2.0 kg.Heat and work, MJSolvent lost, kgHot water, 90 °C28.41.2Ethanol/water, 70 °C14.51.2Pressurized ethanol/water, 150 °C15.11.2Supercritical CO₂ + 5% ethanol5.81.0DES, extract left in solvent1.820.0DES, 90% recovered with water48.52.00255001020
Educational model Computed from reference property data. Liquid routes at 12 kg solvent per kg leaf and 90% recovery. CO₂ at 19.6 kg/kg (the ratio used by Vicente et al. 2013), 95% recycled, 150 bar. DES at 20 kg/kg (Vieira et al. 2022). Heat and pump work are summed in a single bar; electricity and steam are not equivalent in cost or primary energy.
Values in the figure
Hero figure values per kg of dried leaf
Route at default inputsHeating, MJEvaporation, MJWork, MJSolvent lost, kg
Hot water, 90 °C3.624.80.001.2
Ethanol/water, 70 °C1.812.70.001.2
Pressurized ethanol/water, 150 °C5.29.70.211.2
Supercritical CO₂ + 5% ethanol4.60.90.341.0
DES, extract left in solvent1.800.0020.0
DES, 90% recovered with water1.846.60.002.0

In brief · Sensitivity

Solvent recovery reorders the routes; scale-up evidence and solvent status then narrow them

At this page's default inputs a deep eutectic solvent needs the least heat, because none of it is recovered. Recover 90% of it with water as the antisolvent and it needs the most: 48.5 MJ per kg of leaf, against 28.4 MJ for hot water. In the liquid routes every kilogram of solvent recovered is a kilogram evaporated, so higher recovery trades solvent loss for evaporator heat.

Each route at the default model inputs, how solvent recovery moves its energy and solvent loss, its scale-up evidence and capital intensity, and the regulatory status and hazard of its solvent
RouteModel at defaults, per kg leaf heat and work; solvent lostWhat solvent recovery changesScale-up evidence; capital intensity judgmentRegulatory status and hazard of the solvent
Hot water28.4 MJ; 1.2 kg at 90% recoveryEvaporation is 87% of the heat and rises in proportion to the fraction recoveredSimplest equipment, but fails the carnosic acid target (Hirondart); lowerNot flammable
Ethanol/water14.5 MJ; 1.2 kg at 90% recoveryEvaporation is 87% of the heat and rises in proportion to the fraction recoveredConventional solid–liquid extraction; moderateNot in 21 CFR Part 173 Subpart C; § 184.1293 affirms GRAS for a named use (antimicrobial on pizza crusts) and was issued before a general evaluation of ethanol. Flammable
Pressurized liquid15.1 MJ; 1.2 kg at 90% recoveryEvaporation is 65% of the heat, because part of the solvent flashes on letdown; it rises in proportion to the fraction recoveredSánchez-Camargo pooled laboratory runs because pilot-scale PLE equipment was unavailable to them; higherAs ethanol/water, plus hot liquid under pressure; browning at 150 °C and above
Supercritical CO₂5.8 MJ, plus 4.8 MJ of chilled condensing; 1.0 kg CO₂ at 95% recycledCycle duty scales with the CO₂-to-leaf ratio (19.6 kg/kg); 5% ethanol cosolvent brings back 0.94 MJ of evaporationMore than 150 industrial SFE plants by 2014 (cited by Sánchez-Camargo); highestCarbon dioxide listed in 21 CFR 184.1240; high-pressure gas
Deep eutectic solvent1.8 MJ and 20 kg if kept in the extract; 48.5 MJ and 2.0 kg if 90% recoveredRecovery needs a second separation; with 1 kg of water per kg recovered, 18 kg of water must be evaporatedLaboratory studies only among the sources here; lower vessels, recovery train unknownNo DES in 21 CFR 173 Subpart C; component status depends on intended use

Educational model Published evidence Energy and solvent figures are this page's model outputs at its default inputs, not measurements. The model is per kilogram of leaf: it has no economy of scale and omits heat integration, multiple-effect evaporation and vapor recompression, any of which would reduce the steam needed. Capital intensity is EUTECNIQ's qualitative reading. To see a route move, change the recovery in the model (section 03); detail in sections 07 and 08.

01 · The decision

One documented separation puts five routes on the same leaf

Rosemary leaf carries two kinds of target molecule with opposite polarity. Carnosic acid and carnosol are phenolic diterpenes, fat-soluble antioxidant molecules; rosmarinic acid is a water-soluble ester of caffeic acid. A solvent that dissolves one tends to leave the other behind, which makes rosemary a demanding test. It is also a commercial separation: Vieira et al. note that the European Commission authorized extracts of rosemary, standardized on carnosic acid and carnosol, as food additive E 392 in 2010.

Route 1

Hot water

Water at up to 100 °C and atmospheric pressure. The cheapest solvent to buy, with the highest heat of vaporization: 2,257 kJ/kg at its boiling point (CoolProp).

Route 2

Ethanol/water

80% ethanol by weight, below its boiling point. It dissolves both polarities. In Hirondart's pressurized screen (100 °C, 80 bar), 80% ethanol extracted the most rosmarinic and carnosic acid together. Ethanol is flammable.

Route 3

Pressurized liquid

Pressurized liquid extraction (PLE) keeps ethanol/water or water liquid above its boiling point: 150 °C at 100 bar and 183 °C at 130 bar in the cited studies. With water alone it is called pressurized hot water extraction.

Route 4

Supercritical CO₂

CO₂ above its critical point, 30.98 °C and 73.8 bar (CoolProp), where it is dense enough to dissolve lipophilic compounds. The cited pilot runs used 150 to 300 bar at 40 °C, with 5 to 7% ethanol as cosolvent for the more polar compounds.

Route 5

Deep eutectic solvent

A deep eutectic solvent (DES) is a mixture of hydrogen-bond donors and acceptors that stays liquid far below its components' melting points, such as menthol with lauric acid or lactic acid with glucose. Their vapor pressure is very low. For hydrophobic, menthol-based mixtures it has been measured and remains far below that of common organic solvents such as toluene (Dietz et al., ACS Sustain. Chem. Eng. 2019;7:4047–4057).

Next: what the studies measured on rosemary.

02 · Published yield and selectivity

Pressurized ethanol recovered more carnosic acid; supercritical CO₂ made the purer extract

Sánchez-Camargo et al. ran both routes on one lot of leaves. Pressurized 76% ethanol at 150 °C turned 38.5% of the leaf into extract at 105 mg carnosic acid per gram. Two-step supercritical CO₂ gave 4.7% at 443 mg/g. Hirondart et al. state the same trade for their own pressurized extraction: higher yield, lower purity of the active compounds.

Extract yield and carnosic acid content, as published Percent of dried leaf mass; milligrams of carnosic acid per gram of extract

Published extract yield and carnosic acid content by routePLE, 76% ethanol, 150 °C (Sánchez-Camargo et al. 2016, same leaves): extract 38.46% of leaf, carnosic acid 105.0 mg/g extract; Two-step CO₂, 300 then 150 bar (Sánchez-Camargo et al. 2016, same leaves): extract 4.68% of leaf, carnosic acid 443.3 mg/g extract; CO₂ + 5% ethanol, 150 bar (Vicente et al. 2013): extract 7.26% of leaf, carnosic acid 256.6 mg/g extract; PLE, 80% ethanol, 183 °C (Hirondart et al. 2020, same leaves): extract 46.20% of leaf, carnosic acid 45.7 mg/g extract (computed from the reported per-leaf content and yield); Soxhlet reference, 78 °C (Hirondart et al. 2020, same leaves): extract 27.91% of leaf, carnosic acid 63.3 mg/g extract (computed from the reported per-leaf content and yield).Extract, % of leafCarnosic acid, mg/gSánchez-Camargo et al. 2016, same leavesPLE, 76% ethanol, 150 °C38.5105Two-step CO₂, 300 then 150 bar4.7443Vicente et al. 2013CO₂ + 5% ethanol, 150 bar7.3257Hirondart et al. 2020, same leavesPLE, 80% ethanol, 183 °C46.246*Soxhlet reference, 78 °C27.963*025500200400
Published evidence Sánchez-Camargo et al. 2016 (Table 2 and text), Vicente et al. 2013 (Table 2), Hirondart et al. 2020 (Table 3). * Hirondart reports carnosic acid per gram of leaf; the content per gram of extract is computed here as that value divided by the reported yield. Each study used its own plant lot, grinding and analysis, so compare bars within a study.

What else the studies found

  • Water extracts only the polar half. In Hirondart's solvent screen (100 °C, 80 bar), water and 20% ethanol extracted rosmarinic acid but no carnosic acid; carnosic acid appeared from 40% ethanol.
  • High temperatures brown the extract. Hirondart observed Maillard reaction products, a brown color and burnt smell, at 150 °C and above, and notes that such temperatures are usually not recommended for products; their purpose was analytical.
  • Long heating converts carnosic acid to carnosol. Their 8-hour Soxhlet reference held more carnosol than pressurized extraction (4.4 against 1.9 mg/g leaf), which the authors read as carnosic acid degrading to carnosol.
  • A pair of DES phases splits the polarities. Vieira et al. used two immiscible natural DES at once. The polar phase took the rosmarinic acid; the nonpolar phase took 17.54 mg carnosic acid per gram of leaf, 91% of what methanol Soxhlet extraction recovered from the same leaves (computed from their values).

Every published value used on this page

Published rosemary extraction results by route, with conditions and same-study comparisons
Route and studyConditionsReported resultSame-study comparison
Water, pressurized (Hirondart et al. 2020)PLE screen, 0% and 20% ethanol in water, 100 °C, 80 bar, 3 cycles of 5 minRosmarinic acid extracted; carnosic acid not extracted80% ethanol: 10.13 mg rosmarinic acid and 20.6 mg carnosic acid per g leaf
Soxhlet reference, solvent not stated (Hirondart et al. 2020)78 °C, 8 h, 1 g leaf per 12 mL; the paper does not name the Soxhlet solvent and lists only ethanol and water as extraction solventsYield 27.91%; per g leaf: rosmarinic acid 9.86 mg, carnosic acid 17.68 mg, carnosol 4.39 mgCarnosic acid mean 84% of the pressurized mean (computed)
Pressurized 80% ethanol (Hirondart et al. 2020)183 °C, 130 bar, 3 × 1 min; about 50 mL solvent for 3.1 g leafYield 46.20%; per g leaf: rosmarinic acid 10.01 mg, carnosic acid 21.13 mg, carnosol 1.86 mgMeans of 8 runs each; the authors report no significant difference from Soxhlet for rosmarinic acid, carnosic acid or carnosol
Pressurized 76% ethanol (Sánchez-Camargo et al. 2016)150 °C, 100 bar, 20 min, laboratory scaleYield 38.46%; per g extract: carnosic acid 105.0 mg, carnosol 10.7 mg40.4 mg carnosic acid per g leaf (computed: yield × content)
Supercritical CO₂, two steps (Sánchez-Camargo et al. 2016)Pilot, 2 L vessel, 60 g CO₂/min, 40 °C: 300 bar for 60 min, then 150 bar with 7% ethanol for 120 minYield 4.68%; per g extract: carnosic acid 443.3 mg, carnosol 88.9 mg20.7 mg carnosic acid per g leaf, 51% of the pressurized-ethanol value; 4.2 times its purity (computed). Single step at 150 bar with 7% ethanol: yield 6.74%
Supercritical CO₂ with 5% ethanol (Vicente et al. 2013)Pilot, 2 L vessel, 0.55 kg leaf, 60 g CO₂/min for 180 min, 150 bar, 40 °C; separators at 40 °C, recirculation at 50 barYield 7.26%; carnosic acid 25.66% of the extract18.6 mg carnosic acid per g leaf; 19.6 kg CO₂ per kg leaf (both computed)
Biphasic natural DES (Vieira et al. 2022)Lactic acid:glucose (5:1) with menthol:lauric acid (2:1), ultrasound, 60 °C, 60 min, 1 g leaf per 20 g solventPolar phase: rosmarinic acid 1.00 mg, caffeic acid 0.26 mg per g leaf. Nonpolar phase: carnosol 2.30 mg, carnosic acid 17.54 mg per g leafMethanol Soxhlet on the same leaves: rosmarinic acid 1.36, carnosol 7.28, carnosic acid 19.28 mg/g

Why numbers from different studies cannot be ranked. The two Soxhlet references disagree by a factor of 7.3 on rosmarinic acid: 9.86 mg/g in Hirondart's leaves and 1.36 mg/g in Vieira's (computed ratio). Plant lot, drying and analysis moved the result more than most route changes do. EUTECNIQ's first proposed experiment therefore fixes one lot and one analytical method for every route.

Next: what each route costs in heat and solvent.

03 · Energy and solvent model

Evaporating the solvent takes 65 to 87% of the heat in the liquid routes

At 12 kg of solvent per kg of leaf and 90% recovery, evaporating the recovered solvent takes 87% of the heat for hot water and for ethanol/water, and 65% for pressurized ethanol/water, whose hot extract flashes part of its solvent when the pressure is let down. Change the solvent ratio, the recovery and the temperature to see which term moves.

Route
12.0
90
70

Heating solvent and leaf
1.8 MJ
Evaporating solvent for recovery
12.7 MJ
Pump work (electricity)
0.00 MJ
Cooling duty, condensers
12.2 MJ
Solvent not recovered
1.2 kg

The inputs need JavaScript. The figures and the table below show every route at its default inputs.

Mass and energy flows per kg of dried leaf Band width proportional to mass (kg), arrow width to energy (MJ), widths are capped for legibility; labels give the computed values

Liquid routes (shown: ethanol/water at defaults)

Mass and energy flowsheet, Ethanol/waterEthanol/water, 80% ethanol at its default inputs, per kg of dried leaf: solvent circulated 12.0 kg, recovered 10.8 kg, not recovered 1.2 kg; heating 1.8 MJ, evaporation 12.7 MJ, pump work 0.00 MJ, cooling 12.2 MJ. Band widths are proportional to mass and arrow widths to energy, up to a cap.Makeup solvent1.2 kgHeater12.0 kgExtractor70 °C, 1 atm13.0 kgFilter10.8 kgEvaporatorCondenserRecycled10.8 kgHeating1.8 MJLeaf1 kgSpent leaf +1.2 kg solventEvaporation12.7 MJPump work0.00 MJExtract (dry)Cooling12.2 MJ

Supercritical CO₂ at defaults

Mass and energy flowsheet, Supercritical CO₂Supercritical CO₂ with 5% ethanol at its default inputs, per kg of dried leaf: solvent circulated 19.6 kg, recovered 18.6 kg, not recovered 1.0 kg; heating 0.1 MJ, evaporation 0.9 MJ, CO₂ preheater 0.9 MJ and separator 3.6 MJ, pump work 0.34 MJ, cooling 5.6 MJ. Band widths are proportional to mass and arrow widths to energy, up to a cap.Makeup CO₂1.0 kgCO₂ pumpPreheater20.6 kgExtractor150 bar, 40 °Cvalve to 50 barSeparatorCondenserRecycled18.6 kgVented1.0 kgEthanol0.98 kgPump work0.34 MJPreheat0.9 MJLeaf1 kg, batchSeparator heat3.6 MJ+ ethanolEvaporatorEthanol recovery0.9 MJExtract (dry)Cooling5.6 MJ

Deep eutectic solvent at defaults

Mass and energy flowsheet, Deep eutectic solventDeep eutectic solvent (choline chloride:glycerol 1:2 for heat capacity) at its default inputs, per kg of dried leaf: solvent circulated 20.0 kg, recovered 0 kg, not recovered 20.0 kg; heating 1.8 MJ, evaporation 0 MJ, pump work 0.00 MJ, cooling 0 MJ. Band widths are proportional to mass and arrow widths to energy, up to a cap.Makeup DES20.0 kgHeater20.0 kgExtractor60 °C, 1 atm21.0 kgFilter20.0 kgAntisolventprecipitation0 kgEvaporatorCondenserWater0 kgDES back to heater0 kgHeating1.8 MJLeaf1 kgSpent leaf1 kgExtract with20.0 kg DESEvaporation0 MJCooling0 MJ
Educational schematic Block flowsheet with simplified units; no equipment is sized. Solvent that is not recovered is drawn leaving with the spent leaf; dry matter is drawn as one kilogram in and out because the split between spent leaf and extract is the published yield (section 02). For the DES, solvent held back by the spent leaf is not modeled.

All five routes at their current inputs

Per kg of dried leaf. Each route keeps its own inputs when you switch routes above.

All five routes at the current inputs, per kg of dried leaf
RouteInputsHeat, MJWork, MJCooling, MJSolvent lost, kg
Hot water12 kg/kg, 90% recovered, 90 °C28.40.0024.41.2
Ethanol/water12 kg/kg, 90% recovered, 70 °C14.50.0012.21.2
Pressurized liquid12 kg/kg, 90% recovered, 150 °C, 100 bar14.90.2112.21.2
Supercritical CO₂19.6 kg/kg, 95% recovered, 40 °C, 150 bar, ethanol 5% of CO₂5.50.345.61.0
Deep eutectic solvent20 kg/kg, 0% recovered, 60 °C, water 0%, antisolvent 1 kg/kg1.80.00020.0
Method, assumptions and limits

What it calculates. Heat, pump work and cooling per kilogram of dried leaf to bring the solvent to the extraction conditions and to recover it, and the solvent that is not recovered. It does not calculate yield, purity or cost.

Liquid routes (1 to 3). Heating: Qheat = S Σi wi [hi(T, P) − hi(T0, P)] + cp,leaf(T − T0). Recovery: Qevap = S r Σi wi [hivap(1 atm) − hi(T, P)], the enthalpy from the extract's state to saturated vapor at 1 atm; above the boiling point this credits the flash on letdown. Cooling: S r ΣwiΔhvap,i(1 atm). Pump work for route 3: isentropic compression of the liquid at T0 to P, divided by an efficiency of 0.70.

Supercritical CO₂ (route 4). Pump cycle: 4 liquid at 50 bar, 5 K below saturation (9.3 °C); 5 after the pump (isentropic, efficiency 0.70); 1 heated to the extraction pressure and temperature; 2 after an isenthalpic valve to 50 bar; 3 heated in the separator to 40 °C, the separator and recirculation conditions reported by Vicente et al. Per kg CO₂: work h5 − h4, preheat h1 − h5, separator heat h3 − h1, condenser h3 − h4. If the pump outlet is hotter than the extraction temperature (high pressure, low temperature), the preheater becomes a cooler and that heat is counted as cooling duty. Cosolvent ethanol, given as a fraction of the CO₂ mass, is heated and pumped with the CO₂ and then fully evaporated from the extract at 1 atm, from 40 °C.

Deep eutectic solvent (route 5). Heat capacity of choline chloride:glycerol 1:2 and its water mixtures, measured by Leron and Li (2012) at 30 to 80 °C (NIST TRC ThermoML), converted to a mass basis and fitted linearly in temperature for each composition (largest residual below 0.01 kJ/kg·K), interpolated in water content. This DES stands in for the menthol- and lactic acid-based DES of the selectivity data, whose heat capacities were not found. Recovery is modeled as antisolvent precipitation with water at the stated kilograms per kilogram of DES recovered, the water then evaporated from 20 °C at 1 atm. No rosemary study reports that ratio; it is an input.

Variables and units. S kg solvent per kg leaf; r fraction recovered; T °C; P bar; wi mass fraction; h kJ/kg; results in MJ per kg leaf. T0 = 20 °C. Leaf heat capacity 1.5 kJ/kg·K is assumed; it adds at most 0.3 MJ.

Assumptions. Ethanol and water mix ideally (heat of mixing ignored), and each component evaporates at its own normal boiling point. There is no heat integration, multiple-effect evaporation or vapor recompression, any of which would reduce the steam needed, and no heat loss. Solvent not recovered leaves the process. CO₂ losses are a fraction of circulated CO₂ (in practice most of the loss is the vessel inventory vented at each depressurization). Ethanol cosolvent is fully recovered.

Valid range. Inputs are limited to the slider ranges: atmospheric liquids below their boiling points, pressurized liquids at 50 to 150 bar and 100 to 200 °C, CO₂ at 100 to 400 bar and 35 to 80 °C, DES at 30 to 80 °C (the measured range).

What it does not establish. Yield, purity, extraction kinetics, product quality, equipment size, operating cost or environmental impact. Heat and electricity are reported in the same unit but differ in cost and primary energy.

Properties. CoolProp 8.0.0 (Bell et al. 2014): water, ethanol and carbon dioxide reference equations of state; CO₂ enthalpy on the IIR reference, 200 kJ/kg for saturated liquid at 0 °C. Tabulated for the page every 2 °C and at six pressures (liquids) or every 10 bar and 2 °C (CO₂) and interpolated linearly.

Verification. The same equations were evaluated independently in CoolProp for 19 input sets, and the page's model agrees with every result within 1%.

Next: why the CO₂ route behaves differently.

04 · Supercritical CO₂

The separator state and the CO₂-to-leaf ratio fix the heat duty of a CO₂ pump cycle

Per kilogram of CO₂ in a closed cycle, pump work and the two heaters add up to what the condenser removes. With separation at 50 bar and 40 °C that is 244.5 kJ/kg, whatever the extraction pressure.

  1. 1 Extractor CO₂ at the extraction pressure and temperature, 780 kg/m³ at 150 bar and 40 °C.
  2. 2 After the valve At 50 bar the stream is a cold mixture, 26.5% vapor at 14.3 °C, and the extract drops out.
  3. 3 Separator Heated to 40 °C: 181.6 kJ/kg at 150 bar extraction.
  4. 4 Condenser Liquefied 5 K below its 14.3 °C saturation temperature, so the coolant must be colder still.
  5. 5 Pump Back to the extraction pressure: 16.0 kJ/kg at 150 bar, 39.0 kJ/kg at 300 bar.

Raising the pressure from 150 to 300 bar moves heat from the heaters to the pump without changing their sum. The duty per kilogram of leaf therefore scales with the CO₂-to-leaf ratio, 19.6 kg/kg in Vicente's pilot runs. Ethanol cosolvent brings evaporation back: 5% of that CO₂ is 0.98 kg ethanol per kg leaf, 0.94 MJ to evaporate. Vicente et al. describe cosolvent evaporation as an expensive task.

Next: the deep eutectic solvent route.

The modeled CO₂ cycle on a pressure–enthalpy diagram Pressure (bar, log scale) against enthalpy (kJ/kg); updates with the CO₂ inputs above

Supercritical CO₂ extraction cycle on a pressure–enthalpy diagramPressure–enthalpy diagram of carbon dioxide (CoolProp) with the saturation dome, the critical point at 30.98 °C and 73.77 bar, the 40 °C isotherm and the modeled cycle at 150 bar and 40 °C: 4 condensed liquid at 50 bar (223 kJ/kg), 5 after the pump (239), 1 heated to extraction conditions (285), 2 after the valve at 50 bar, a cold liquid–vapor mixture (285), 3 heated in the separator to 40 °C (467).5010020040020030040050040 °Cliquid + vaporcritical point45123Enthalpy, kJ/kg (IIR reference)bar
Educational model Saturation dome, critical point and 40 °C isotherm computed with CoolProp 8.0.0 (dashed line: reference isotherm). Cycle states as listed, at the route 4 inputs; pump efficiency 0.70 and 5 K subcooling are assumptions.

05 · Deep eutectic solvents

A deep eutectic solvent stays in the extract unless a second separation removes it

A DES cannot be boiled off like ethanol. That spares the evaporator and creates three engineering problems instead: viscosity, recovery and residue.

Viscosity

Thick solvents extract slowly or not at all

Vieira et al. measured 14 to 1,654 mPa·s at 40 °C for ten natural DES, against 0.65 mPa·s for water (CoolProp): 21 to 2,533 times as viscous (computed). The most viscous, citric acid:glycerol, extracted none of the four target compounds, which the authors attribute to compromised mass transfer. Viscosity falls with temperature and added water, and water also shifts polarity.

Recovery

Taking the solvent back costs a second separation

Rosa et al. (2026) identify low volatility as the reason extract purification and solvent recovery remain difficult, and list resin adsorption, antisolvent precipitation and direct formulation as the approaches explored. In this page's model, recovering 90% of the DES with 1 kg of water per kg leaves 18 kg of water to evaporate: 48.5 MJ per kg leaf, more than three times the ethanol/water route.

Residue

Left in place, the solvent is the product

Vieira et al. propose using the extract in the DES, which kept the compounds stable for 90 days. At 1 g leaf per 20 g solvent the nonpolar phase holds about 1.8 mg carnosic acid per gram, against 443 mg/g in the two-step CO₂ extract (computed, assuming the solvent splits evenly by mass between the two phases). The DES components then need a regulatory status that fits the product: 21 CFR Part 173 Subpart C, the U.S. list of solvents in food, names no DES (eCFR, as of November 2026).

Heat capacity is the DES advantage: 2.20 to 2.36 kJ/kg·K for choline chloride:glycerol at 30 to 80 °C (Leron and Li 2012, converted to a mass basis), about half that of water.

Viscosity at 40 °C Millipascal-seconds, log scale; DES abbreviations as in Vieira et al. 2022

Viscosity at 40 °C of ten natural deep eutectic solvents, water and ethanolViscosity at 40 °C, logarithmic scale: Water 0.653 mPa·s; Ethanol 0.819 mPa·s; Ca:Gly (1:1) 1654 mPa·s; B:Gly (1:2) 606.36 mPa·s; T:Gly (1:30) 439 mPa·s; La:B (2:1) 374.6 mPa·s; P:La (3:1) 179.52 mPa·s; Me:Lau (2:1) 58.84 mPa·s; Me:La (1:2) 58.84 mPa·s; La:Glu (5:1) 42.94 mPa·s; B:EG (1:3) 35.69 mPa·s; Me:My (8:1) 13.96 mPa·s.Water0.7Ethanol0.8Ca:Gly (1:1)1,654B:Gly (1:2)606T:Gly (1:30)439La:B (2:1)375P:La (3:1)180Me:Lau (2:1)58.8Me:La (1:2)58.8La:Glu (5:1)42.9B:EG (1:3)35.7Me:My (8:1)14.00.1110010,000mPa·s, log scale
Published evidence DES: Vieira et al. 2022, Table 2 (Me:Lau and Me:La are reported with the same value). Water and ethanol: CoolProp 8.0.0 at 1 atm. Ca citric acid, Gly glycerol, B betaine, T trehalose, La lactic acid, P proline, Me menthol, Lau lauric acid, Glu glucose, EG ethylene glycol, My myristic acid; molar ratios in parentheses.

Next: what calling a route green would require.

06 · Life-cycle view

A route is greener only after a full-process comparison per unit of product

Calling a solvent natural or green describes the solvent, not the process. Life-cycle assessment (LCA) compares whole systems against one functional unit, from raw material to waste, following ISO 14040 and ISO 14044. The energy model above is one input to such a comparison, and an incomplete one.

Functional unit

Per gram of carnosic acid at specification

Per kilogram of leaf, pressurized ethanol looks efficient. Per gram of carnosic acid at a purity specification, the four-times-purer CO₂ extract may need less purification downstream, while pressurized ethanol needs about half as much leaf (Sánchez-Camargo values). The ranking can reverse with the unit.

Boundary

What this model leaves out

Steam, electricity and refrigeration differ in primary energy and emissions. The model also omits solvent production (including DES components, ethanol and CO₂), solvent losses and waste treatment, drying of the extract, cleaning and the equipment itself.

Screening scores

An eco-footprint radar is not an LCA

Hirondart et al. scored pressurized extraction at 2.96 against 100 for Soxhlet on six green-extraction criteria for an analytical method. That is a useful screen; it is not an ISO life-cycle assessment and was not scaled.

Published LCAs

Comparative LCAs exist for other materials

Bruna et al. (2025) compared subcritical water and supercritical CO₂ for apple pomace, and Gaalich et al. (2026) reviewed LCA studies of supercritical processes. The sustainability and LCA page summarizes the first result.

Next: what drives capital intensity.

07 · Capital intensity and scale-up

Pressure, flammability and the recovery train set capital intensity before any vendor quote

No costs are estimated here. The table ranks routes qualitatively from the operating conditions in the cited studies and the equipment each would need.

Qualitative capital intensity and scale-up considerations by route
RoutePressure in the cited studiesSolvent status and hazardRecovery equipmentScale-up evidenceRelative capital intensity
Hot water1 atmNot flammableEvaporator with the largest duty per kg solventSimplest equipment; fails the carnosic acid target (Hirondart)Lower
Ethanol/water1 atmNot in 21 CFR Part 173 Subpart C; § 184.1293 affirms GRAS for a named use (antimicrobial on pizza crusts) and was issued before a general evaluation of ethanol. FlammableEvaporator or distillation, condenser, solvent storageConventional solid–liquid extractionModerate
Pressurized liquid100–130 bar at 150–183 °CAs ethanol/water, plus hot liquid under pressure; browning at 150 °C and abovePressure-rated vessels and pumps, letdown, evaporatorSánchez-Camargo pooled laboratory runs because pilot-scale PLE equipment was unavailable to themHigher
Supercritical CO₂150–300 bar at 40 °CCarbon dioxide listed in 21 CFR 184.1240; high-pressure gasHigh-pressure extractor, separators, chilled condenser, pump; cosolvent evaporatorMore than 150 industrial SFE plants by 2014 (cited by Sánchez-Camargo)Highest
Deep eutectic solvent1 atmNo DES in 21 CFR 173 Subpart C; component status depends on intended useUndefined: antisolvent or resin step plus water evaporation, or none if the extract stays in the DESLaboratory studies only among the sources hereLower vessels; recovery train unknown

Qualitative judgment The last column is EUTECNIQ's reading of operating pressure and the number of unit operations, not a cost estimate. Hazard analysis for flammable solvent and combustible dust is covered on the process-engineering page.

Next: how EUTECNIQ would rank the routes.

08 · How EUTECNIQ would decide

EUTECNIQ would keep every route that no other route beats on all five objectives

Recovery, purity, energy, solvent loss and scale-up risk compete. A weighted score hides the trade. EUTECNIQ proposes to keep the non-dominated set, the routes that no other route matches or beats on every objective (a Pareto set), and to spend experiments on the numbers that could change its membership.

Decision matrix: five routes against five competing objectives
RouteRecovery of carnosic acid publishedPurity of the product publishedHeat and work, MJ/kg leaf model, defaultsSolvent lost, kg/kg leaf model, defaultsScale-up risk judgment
Hot waterNone detectedNot reported28.41.2Low; fails the carnosic acid target
Ethanol/water17.7 mg/g in the Soxhlet reference (Hirondart et al.; solvent not stated), 84% of the PLE mean in the same study (difference not significant per the authors)63 mg/g extract in the same Soxhlet reference (computed)14.51.2Low to moderate; flammable solvent
Pressurized liquid21.1 to 40.4 mg/g, the highest mean in both studies46 to 105 mg/g extract15.11.2Moderate to high; pressure, browning above 150 °C
Supercritical CO₂18.6 to 20.7 mg/g, 51% of PLE in the same study257 to 443 mg/g extract5.8, plus 4.8 MJ of chilled condensing1.0 CO₂Moderate; established at industrial scale, capital-intensive
Deep eutectic solvent17.5 mg/g, 91% of methanol Soxhlet in the same studyAbout 1.8 mg/g solvent phase (computed)1.8 if kept; 48.5 if 90% recovered20 if kept; 2.0 if recoveredHigh; recovery and residue unresolved

On these numbers no route is matched or beaten on all five columns by another route. Hot water leaves the set on a hard limit: it does not extract carnosic acid. Cross-study recovery figures are indicative only (section 02).

Confirmatory experiments, in the order EUTECNIQ would run them

  1. Set one reference basis. One leaf lot, one particle size, one validated HPLC method for rosmarinic acid, carnosic acid and carnosol, and an exhaustive extraction (pressurized 80% ethanol, as Hirondart used for raw-material assay) as the 100% basis. This defines "recovery" for every route.
  2. Run every route on that lot. Two solvent ratios each, mass balance closed on solids and solvent. This puts recovery and purity on one basis, replacing the cross-study table.
  3. Measure extraction curves. Recovery against solvent-to-leaf ratio for the two leading routes. This sets the ratio, which the model shows drives energy almost linearly.
  4. Measure solvent retention and loss. Solvent held by the spent leaf, vent losses and CO₂ vented per batch. This sets the recovery fraction, an assumption on this page.
  5. Test thermal limits. Carnosic acid to carnosol conversion and browning against temperature and time. This sets the temperature ceiling for pressurized extraction.
  6. Resolve the DES questions. Measure viscosity against water content and temperature, recovery by resin or antisolvent and residual DES in the final extract, and confirm the regulatory status of each component. This decides whether the DES route stays in the set.
  7. Meter energy at pilot scale. Steam, electricity and refrigeration for the remaining routes. Measurements then replace this page's model.
  8. Build the life-cycle inventory. ISO 14044 inventory from the measured balances, per gram of carnosic acid at specification. This decides whether any route can be called greener.

Rule for dropping a route. A route leaves the set as soon as another route matches or beats it on every objective, or when it fails a hard limit such as the purity specification or the regulatory status of a solvent. If no route meets the specification at an acceptable energy and solvent loss, EUTECNIQ would say so and stop.

09 · Sources

References cited in this demonstration

  1. Sánchez-Camargo AP, García-Cañas V, Herrero M, Cifuentes A, Ibáñez E. Comparative study of green sub- and supercritical processes to obtain carnosic acid and carnosol-enriched rosemary extracts with in vitro anti-proliferative activity on colon cancer cells. Int J Mol Sci. 2016;17(12):2046. doi.org/10.3390/ijms17122046 (extraction conditions and yields used; no biological activity is discussed here)
  2. Hirondart M, Rombaut N, Fabiano-Tixier AS, Bily A, Chemat F. Comparison between pressurized liquid extraction and conventional Soxhlet extraction for rosemary antioxidants, yield, composition, and environmental footprint. Foods. 2020;9(5):584. doi.org/10.3390/foods9050584
  3. Vicente G, Molina S, González-Vallinas M, García-Risco MR, Fornari T, Reglero G, Ramírez de Molina A. Supercritical rosemary extracts, their antioxidant activity and effect on hepatic tumor progression. J Supercrit Fluids. 2013;79:101–108. doi.org/10.1016/j.supflu.2012.07.006 (extraction conditions and yields used)
  4. Vieira C, Rebocho S, Craveiro R, Paiva A, Duarte ARC. Selective extraction and stabilization of bioactive compounds from rosemary leaves using a biphasic NADES. Front Chem. 2022;10:954835. doi.org/10.3389/fchem.2022.954835
  5. Rosa GP, Barreto MC, Seca AML, Pinto DCGA. Ionic liquids and deep eutectic solvents for polyphenol extraction: opportunities and limitations. Int J Mol Sci. 2026;27(8):3538. doi.org/10.3390/ijms27083538
  6. Leron RB, Li M-H. Molar heat capacities of choline chloride-based deep eutectic solvents and their binary mixtures with water. Thermochim Acta. 2012;530:52–57. doi.org/10.1016/j.tca.2011.11.036; data from NIST TRC ThermoML
  7. Bell IH, Wronski J, Quoilin S, Lemort V. Pure and pseudo-pure fluid thermophysical property evaluation and the open-source thermophysical property library CoolProp. Ind Eng Chem Res. 2014;53(6):2498–2508. doi.org/10.1021/ie4033999 (CoolProp 8.0.0 used)
  8. ISO 14044:2006. Environmental management — Life cycle assessment — Requirements and guidelines (Amd 1:2017, Amd 2:2020; confirmed 2022). iso.org/standard/38498.html
  9. Bruna L, Marty C, Draye M, Cravotto G, Chatel G. Subcritical or supercritical? A comparative life cycle assessment of bioactive compound extraction from apple pomace. Clean Environ Syst. 2025;18:100311. doi.org/10.1016/j.cesys.2025.100311
  10. Gaalich I, Lee D, Aymonier C, Sonnemann G, Olchowka J, Philippot G, Loubet P. Environmental impacts of supercritical fluids processes: a critical review of life cycle assessment studies. Environ Impact Assess Rev. 2026;116:108106. doi.org/10.1016/j.eiar.2025.108106
  11. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 21 CFR Part 173, Subpart C (solvents), 21 CFR 184.1240 (carbon dioxide) and 21 CFR 184.1293 (ethyl alcohol). Section list retrieved November 1, 2026. ecfr.gov

Health information notice. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Nothing on this site is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease, and nothing here is medical advice.

Read the full notice

The information is for general education only. It does not replace advice, diagnosis or treatment from a qualified health professional, or any medication a clinician has prescribed. Do not start, stop or change any medicine, supplement or herbal product because of something you read here. Talk to your doctor or pharmacist first, especially if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, have a medical condition, take any medicines, are preparing for surgery, or are caring for a child. Research findings, traditional uses and safety data are reported as their sources state them; they are not recommendations or claims about any product. If you think you may have a medical emergency, call your doctor or 911 at once.

EUTECNIQ Sciences sells no supplements or health products today and receives nothing from any product or ingredient mentioned on this site; any commercial interest it later has in an ingredient will be stated on that ingredient’s page.

Ready to start a development project?

Tell us about an ingredient you want to specify, verify or license. Questions? Email [email protected]